CTA Case No. 1689 (Decision)

REPURLIC OF THE PHILIPPl~ES <_;r,URT OF TAX APPEALS QUEZON Ctl'Y ..... ; 9 .. <:' t< l - .. .. 1n t.~ an ?P l r m is on t 0 c ... C~" t ' r; '- ..o l95" , t 195'~~ t" '1 ?'J 1r ,$ ly b.t to t ~ ... ~ t 95 5i .. t1o ... 5-' .f! t s 33 d . ' -r;'r 2- ~ 1 ;r,? 3� , '> ne . t. ~') 155

.,... 95;;, t. 1 1 ~. l. f3' n f)~ ' 1 %. t 0 '1 �"' .:,! , .t t on t n t , r. �.t''lon 1 tt�tien;;) c t ncco ... fo ... .t (l) 1 .� 0.- .. ' () 7 156

/ ~c- - J fHl., ~:r t0 157

... -' t 1 158

t 1):lpon~a � ~ ;tn a lC'vt~,.d t 1:3 ttaC'it.l ; .;9nttt f t~ �~ ol 1."'*.,41! b \l:"t1t1�41:r> as ,l~ �.J.etton J.roo It~&,.<� s i � eo."' . ��ol' 1956 on ~..h1! grou.n s t ....t f' ;.~1 ~ to prQ 0:~ in�try n�~ dtie,. n.s~~}'i ~.-� th~t,~ 59V~~i\..~s h.ld b�� ~ a~ P~tti~ by ~ectton 30( �J(1 ) or t . tl.l.\s t !r.;o 1a:1.. c., a$',. !at .r.1 or h �~t~~ & eo ~ , tt1b1t~ p~t1tton~r th wrJS o. ,~, ~oo. e , <,.. lQ;reh 1 ,. 1,.,; :!'~rio( :S'a, sc"c., m'l f1 ~i;pt..!tr�"'Jt" l9 :t 195~ for tho rf.$�,;;;1 ~'~~"*t'tt.$ ' f1,.le:~i> p 1 ~ tr.ty l ,, 1 J5 !~ 'tJo r-�::H':::~":v'~ 31, 195~~ in G .~tu'!~� t.tcn 'lllth lt~ tnv zttlG te: riv O�!lZ ~o ?:t1tiot~~..i-:'S th�at lJt>tit-iofl~n�

9 n 0 tili 1 "' 't Ot'' ... '1 . tr d pp 1e � t x- 1� t - tty. u { � t ,. 160

\/ Jo ;: 1 tl J � f ... t n:; ~~. �� - �;. 0 0 1 t) . te .t t n .... P nc �'.0~ ... s ol~ t t n t' 161

~CIS . t ..., .. ~ c . /~ 1: 1t t ~- I .t h ! t tJ:nan~ .... it... ; �f t ~ t pr 1 � t. 162

t � � � ). Moreover, � �t . ). t. t t t t i� 16 3

-..., t:o, 1 39 . 10 (1) t 0' 2, t P� ti 1 Q 1Ptn. s~J tD.Xl an..1 �t� to" bl tt tp (2) cm:nnts of .. '1 .� t ~l Y t P~ t o 1 ... 0 t 'l~ 1.! t~ t _t n n t. ncl lb � 1o. t.s etiou 25; :I t - ' 164

l 01~ � .tey dtVi�� t" '( ,., 2 et o � ' t" pl � i 165

1 s Gp - �� t . o : :� 166

� 3 167

I .. 19 n -1 . :p~-1 th� di - !' 168

l"� 15 nc . o.J.' t t e� ~ ,<I' . ,or , tl-J n bi;:� '.t eo-.t e !' ... i. t; nti that it ' � tr:tat t iQ; ltP b ... � t0 0 ...

tl oth . . ( -,'"' -. 170

? ( � t lt is urged .. \! 171

t 1 1' t �� t � ' i> 17 2

... ' t ... 173

t- ti' t 1 l'\ti 0� t>lit .. 1, J:t ol' ..t. 0 Ln � t., p � �1d s � 174

..,. 175

� - ' 6 1 t-1

.. � � ese, gets a v �' . ' �� I .1' � v. th urf t -. n !'b .rul � ,.; :"1 e 11 n I f () Bt �t:tt 3 ~ .. t t!t ~ r 0 � ,, oes so he t. is ' .t j~ ;1"�7"7

1 tr t1 t j, ,. t n ./ " 0 nt rJ. c~ 0 . r ~~ 17'8

.. .. � nt � ..... c J ,. o- iJ ' r � i' 17 9

� - � , / 1 "� '. '- t -~ O!'dr h 180

~~ 181

~ �8 r st 0 a0 by n ' c::o... � � It ' ,, 182