CTA Case No. 2405 (Decision)

R ~i. C OF' TH~ II .IPPJ~J-.:8 r:.t�f Tt 1' AX APPE. Lt! l.r "'t)N CITY 1 U.s f ��� ' � 2 ' ... ,'V~ ~~ y t;U ll> - ... ... .. .. - - - - - . - - - ..~. 'r t u r "l � 251

DtCihl ~ ... C 1 " 1,., A:3 J. ,~t, � ~~ )' Pet!t1on r ..:ile 'Hi G :..b il "�c. ill t..f Cus ous vh �ri the ,. 1 ~1n � . omlds , J �� Til.�. ta~t i.bat �tbe ~ u.rea ... o aid t im ~t s rras re chart~ a � aa go a L r t a � ~a n te of the (Lfectiv�ity o t ~ Gt.t~toms � . e in un , l9'? l1 t o. �t. e � xecution 'the atorestat .),d contr�act h� ws that Lhe 1.>ure of oms has be n aw r since tha tlatinn1n6 of ~ 1 ck t st tutor5 au horit ~o collect 2 52

~CI!:i ~ ...... CT ,f~l'; Nu . c! lt . !; j rr� . tr ch . es o. ex rt ear, � at t.he ;ttort of Da ao; and 4t. hat t olle O~tll! 0 r er Cl .&Ci i n 1D tb t" en 1oned ~ote t $ et. �nl the a 1u1'tl le�a 1ty t ttlo i wit.il>n t :l".S Cl 1'1,', & n u icle � � or e�.x.pol!t t th � �ort ao . ? t. t i onex� app � l �aid � e.1s iG.n t .a r - u ondent on M!lY 51 l .96�9� v:n A ril 7 , 197~ . resp&Jlde.nt o Ccl- neth r o no the �oll.setion of err tra cu.art! oa t ~ c opra up .r:ts of pet1llion.-x at the Port ct � v- 1,.). OUk t e eon a �t r 1 l l ; (.ct) ~h tlle � � not. the rra tr en r r;es in qu atio re re o.na tl � Pe 1t1on r c ntend that t1e c lleot o or t e t Arrastre:.; rv e is n .utno.r1 "e .1lle , 1 , tt s�o ing nQ p:rovJ. 1o.u in the 'l:nritt and c usto s Cod IJ t e rt t av , it ave on o t s in the .hu.�ts 2 53

" J. p "1.1 n i b 1 n vU r � r c r~ 1 cati t c �r 1 :e u 1/l. b �vos1 1 t 1: cr o. t � it 1 r s n pos- tQ 0 w ct 0 u he 1 r \' 1 to t 'IN ' h t a l0 � y of t the tr h b l' rec 0 r t tiel � h t n<:: 1 1t a1 t. r r~ p�r � t. is 0e t.d he in ti 0 t t r 0 t.r ... a he rti l .t'ro �t ort � 1 .. 1 Q . e t f1nu ' p rt 1 s i jl"" .)� 5) 0 t; l:nri & c ,v en re ~ v !fie 2 54

iJEt...IY vN ... ~ A C �~ N � 2 5 wit n e ;supe::Yi$iCio., an nt t' ll Pb.ll.1..,p:ula:i u.pon ba uu~t. c ,.a4� e s.". <i.Ullil 1:n .r~c"' bt; a C:t>o>Jdi~.ttlon r , ~/ Pn � i ir~ � rovid-e i~o:: u.~ r~ ..a~ �� cha ...as on e �port ea.r o at ttl V 1�t � .t Dav Ot w are of ttt& p1nJ.on that t h<a C::�l w:1f 1o.ne-r f Cu to~ , th the r v~l o � tl {)~c.r~t '�1 at )11n&l'iC8; rj bas t .!l .:.:. t.nox; J 1. ./ 4? , 19'73 �) 1 i.:.."liJ/:0 tt:L' ~ ii~tc J t, . ~ . A . f'' 4 ' �rt ~ l l I t iJtJ~. .II V � W1t.l. .;,".'espec 1. t v !, ..:: ~.1!;1 ~ J.g.t;U tit1 r ~,at the a un ~b~ Cntl..t't,IJ 1n U� ion loii) il'l D.Q.t c . � ens - 255

/ 1 hr t � .:.n .r . 1.1- ' 1,-, � 2 56