CTA Case No. 680 (Decision)

MP'UBLlC OP' TR . PmLJJIPf~ COURT O.F TA.h. APPEAU NAN � � II titl.C t t - .. v - ll ��� � .. ,. I :i. l � ... end � - - - " � ... .... .... i "': i -. (,~ , 0 11 j.( � t. ..... hu . � c ' {} ') � t~' n 17" (: cf t I''. ..... ~,

. ( � 6 . ... t J ,;..y .7 , L' St , r�i$ e� � i. :r a .I l ., .,. -. ""' ~ (.H.t .. ..... \.. 't � Ir~ I , � '. �n {.r ..... 'P h h GJC> ~ �� .:; y 1 � 1 ~/I l. tls ,.. fun .n .,. .~r . t ( () .�.. r~ \; u t'. ~ r�. 1 ro .' t � 0 ,.n .f I ' t � � c. - .. r

> cr.r:.r . .: ... � .. ,. �f . f� ~ K~ . ~ � I _j i j t\' 0 . c h r ;;,>!i" . � fu~l. .\ Ct r; c � 125. �, ' rrt� ~ .. '--~�- t ....f ,l. ~1�'c~ l�~ .. . .�.&'n v 1 II,,. e ir f '�' ... '� ) (i L' ad i l": . .. 7"td 1, c+ l.c-. . �lie ;:,r; ~ . l f\ l't ,., r ;J. X J-i � c .Ju .... ~ 1 .. ' I : : I-"' f ~t ac ~~r ~-n ~ 323

..... ~! .. .. . ' I ... .. ' rt f t ~, t )~.. ., ~~ t .... c .: � 324 _j

e- � r. n ci ' J: � Ji 19 �� .' sc .. f . � ,., �� l i J ,r< }, " J1 ( "t .Lnt l 325 L_

I .� � (i j cr � �� -r n I ... �-~- ;L ,, c. 1 .; i' l ~ ....�� t.�.i. : !. ... ( L x~ ' ) '� ''<. . � t .� ; {,. ~~ H, ..,. .., �'<~, l' ' ,I ' c . J. - . � c . i c i 1 (; f � ' _� !:. �~ .,, � . . ,....; ~ ... 326 J

. ::r �;J, '� ,j ... - .. T.. , .� \ r~ ~ &' ~ .� \ � � Ji .l 7 .. t lL ill ~ n Eli' 0 . ,-.;- f s .. ('., }'r. .. fl � h � ... (. t'ng � � v .. . . ~. � A, .t'J < t. ':te r .4" ll., :l X (: -7 .r .. . Xf., .� j. � �~ h ... ~ t' j J~.,ae ~I 1 �t �"' .11 7 ~.. ~ ..f �,.' l 1- � !'r " r .~ . .... �::;) ""�,.:,: .. ~ ,f' ~~ t 't l' ,I t io�! .... '��. C:\'l't".r. ~u t i t (I 4 ti ' t:. e f . t. "' � J. � ' $ dU 327

I I ... ' ... J - ... I ~ l� cl .1, X 328

!}:(' . ... c. .. 329

' ~~(;'f"'; �._., ;�.~ .. . ~ . -~ . -=. . ~'":� � t � l~- 330

� .. t ,. 331

- .. l r l I I 332

1 ln e ... l � 333

. (J .i,C ....; o. 111') - l.t � ... 7 . ~~ � � u. � 295 334

.. 1,. (' i . ... 1:.> - 335 j

. c.... . . . ->:: . ') .:.~~!,, :~ � .. � \... 6 ,,~ ... I,. ... � ~- :� 336

- 17 337

. . . . '. . 1.! ,__{!, ~ ... . .. �~/ .. 338

c. � � .'' ... 1.. ;: 339

t I . ~l c . ~ . \. .... l � � n r 340

I . r-. .'' r

.... , .,,. ., "' " ,_.';'..t. p: ;... .� . ""'� 6 . I' 342

" ..' ' ' � t I '. t: I. 343

i on , 'i�l'i l t r� C' t � r. ~.... ~ 0 ity � I ,_ r~ l i t .i tI 't �! � J:n - t c .. ,-y (" . ~\ c y ;,o;, 3 4 tl

,c. !. .. . :. ~:t:. ~-~;l ~ ll - l,:r-\~ .. ... :,t' ) - ('./.: .' .. ry .~ . .. � n G. ' � � . ;;. ' .... l ~~ ..... . ,c..: �1 0 � (! !' ... ~~: (':'_ !; r ~ .t ..:: i '"'. 1'):) #' ; 345

- t v " al - a~� - i �., tt J 11 l ���; et i r 1. U� Cl� "'- 346

. 1 . 1�~� - '27 - l y :r ,i l cl r -ct ~i ... 'i � h ., "'')l :\ (;_ n iJ th � t.t t c t � <1: . i t I:! u �'1C t , . """ CI' jlt_! ... '~ -lf t" n "'h "' ear; � l .,_ "' c ~i ; lj. �.. :t\ a b.: .. " - " 1 � ;; . i~ l.:; .;. (l ,� l'r nkl:t � t� �-~ � - ." o ' 't '\Ct � o. 25 r :.crt 'i i ,., r,_, ob ). n r q lt-, t ~ '� { , j' � i t. i """ (1:~ � ~ c � � r,n � ( 7 .-�r c 1 i \Ct . '( . 1~5 . h~tr i. vl nd :ttt a l ~() - - -- 34 I

..... - ~ c� :; .Jt.) a c c } v. G'fi.� ;;f . ( ... �� 1 o. L- 1 ..... ~ . i t .t 4, i . � ) �� ~t ... . ~l. t ar.: ' e:. n� n t Ci i .. 1 t ......... f ":nt .rn .i rl '.I...:f.':.t fl ~fl�.l t. t a ' Ot d. ~' ' 348

- :.c i~l " ���! - -- c. 1 � , ,. Ct". ~ r.J: . 6 � # � o�� � � .;.> "�nti (t t � t' tt.: HI- t t 1. l t -u ~y l L.' 11 57 � . t i t '"! t ' ~ "~ ' .i ..l f <.. l ' �� ' 1. �Ct \:,f., � :r .�, . .".' .1.. � J u �� 2 7 , � ..Ju ~. ...( f l r:.? � � J 'Ch l t tH~ .. .� c ,. a~d ., t na �e fh; }' . .. '"' � t~ i r ~H ""h c .II. fl C J f x- 1: 1 !~ ... '�h�:. "i d J m�n 1'1 a " ,u ac ,(, . eI t :r l-1: .0 ! ..;. l it t '' l "t. l; I �-� ~ 'a ~ 34 9

rl:.1 -r. �~I\ ~~r - � c... c: t . �..� ~.~.~: .f I~ . ?(, ... . . f ., .n. ' c ft; . t J. n '-O- .,~.J.,;' ' t ~l l " J. '.JfH... y {1 .... C(l".>Q-!...1. l 1e T :.' 'i l.1L.!�; . i ! e il� ny � J� l r. � ,...... ' I i.9':{ � 1l 1 t c �)1 -;:er:..... 1~f ..., ~ f r . ' G �!: . . .. <'� ' ..,. L 7 ~~ . -1.. ... 1.1 ~'J, � r "-�~ .......,v..,...~..,...+ .�' v. 1 (. J. . . '� :t"!.. .~ � .. . ~�..0 � _ o .... ,.., f :It. t n �y +itrJ- 3-:'v rn :r ... "" u: � \, �r i. :...r ---! ....~ ... ..~. .{... l i ... ~ I. ....":� _,. n ~it � ( l .... !e 0 t t e :�~(';r. i tJ �.. t . .h � .:f.P� . ,,t ... . � t c-f t. t.h� .. ,:... t v of .' . ' "�' I. t tC' ::�xtc i (i 'f,.. X ~ .t!: . . tf ,{. ..��~t:C "' .. ' {'... * .. j r'; ~ ~~7 ' ._v\CJY ~ � t 11 �� < � J � 350

� '1 t~ ~ .f{). l- 1 d .l 1,. ~ � e .n.. i t .ri t t � ty (.. r� .. c. lt: ~ ir I '� C, s 351

WUU"UBLIC 01' THE PHILIPPIND ':DURT OF TAX APPEALS UANJJ � .. '�6 . .. ., .. eo r ;f \ t. ....' c n , 1. 0 r i .t' - c .. u t;on � � iii � i o. ?1 � � l 1 -;C. r 1. .. rl 1t t 0 c n r 1 il' n� . .f... 1.. furc .l 2 ~ (& ": g v t n- '"h � ul t .. o. �....-1 .-.l f ct t ~ tn f r ,, .t... ..; . n ~e .,. fro nf ; t i~ ' tj h la .:�-. � f � :r t� 352

.. I t. 1Cl l jQ ... ~.l!. Cou c c! � t .Jt 0 "' c tton l f c� � e .l.. ;:d v , i 1 �� ~c, ��. 7; ''.":�J' l {. X � � I ' o... Cr l ,, � .. G � �� � ..... � .,1. '� '� � 0 n� � � � '}., � 0 1�c, ......... f ~ . !~~ .c.;.. ...t l d � e r�ip :: 0 on ,. i t'Jl �t � � 353 .'