CTA Case No. 4721 (Decision)
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES COURT OF TAX APPEALS QUEZON CITY WANDER (PHILIPPINES), INC_ Petitioner. - versus - C_T_A_ CASE NO_ 4721 Promulgated: 19_!&_* THE COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE, _JA_N _t_t Respondent_ X- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - X DECISION r� .-. ..-1.--�.t�r�l"':�tl� Ti 'I-1.~-. ,.-.,.-1 �-�o �-� �- "1' .-. t-, .-. !- 1. ..r~t4--.iLt- '.) .1.':';:! -._=1� ��=-��� �- -._. ..i. r� t i .�.~-��r-��,r�,r.--.�;���-��r��-:....~.......... 1 r�-:�:.t�ljo=�~�=~�-.-.::.,-i 1�1-1 �-� ..... -� �-� 1-l-l-�.:-l...H-. 1J'."l-d-,'._.-.l._f..l-l�!-;�1-1;�:-::r, 1-'-.--.�".�--."��-�1 rt--'1- '���--''.�--~lU''-'��-���t.�~-:��.. .-:-�.1_1'-��-�-'I�l t�r��' T. .T-l--~�~--�-.,�.l-..l t1-�����tl o�='! 1�1-1~~;:::.�:-t1� r�r�:-:.��-=� �r..���(-���-�fl(-..1+r�-:�:....t�lt..:"'.�:-�' 1�;:�:-:�. ~'i r�:-:�.r-111-�;::�-:�. ,:.,:.:,.. .~.-~!��.=.i. ~ r� ,:::.1- 1- 01_1_1-lr:j I �-� �-� -� � i~'-� ... �-� .� LJ. ... l .... t.-~1-k-1-.l,._- r.-�'.-~. t�.1�.t.1.���..�J�t-1�~��1� 1�..:-;.. li�.-:~..1.k.-!.1~��� !r'��-�'�r� ��.:I�~-� r�1��-.�,�1�~--- t-1���-�-���/ 1�r-11---J--)�.lH�->-::.-:.' .�:-1.�1�1'-��.1 :.-:....:.�,.1.."_'�.:-:�. ~�.-.:-1.-n<,:i:-:.-.,--:�. fr) r 103 ---~----------~- ~--~--~-----�-----�-..)
CT..i.\. CM"E NO, 4721 �:-.. t�; ,�-t � �� ~.i� � - 1937 -Deficiency Income Tax �.::..dd � T.3..i2~:: .~; D1J.tie:: �� p 13.14 ~:. ::. 9(J9 0') 12,2 (JC:,_2�1l.(Jf) C:?.pitZl.l E::per~<iitu re.: I�f::?t �r:~J~-ia.t)le Irl;))!L1e- p l,22?.,69d (J(1 T:::.x Due T1Prt-('n p 1.970,246.(H) T:::!X Pa.id Defkie.ncy� Iw:.Arw Tax ,.::,,dd. 2(::~; Surcharg._,e i".dd: 2 o::;; Inte.re::t frcrn -r:. 4- 16 ::!, t�.) 9-2 1-G��;1 Cc-mpr(Tni�;e F�'?.nalty TOTAL AMOUNT PUE ANP COLLECTif:Lf: 1987 - Deficiency Sales Tax Nd. Ta.x:::t.ble Sal.:::::; �6...dd � Tax::Jble S::Jies tn �6.FPCES Adjusted T3:D::1.t.le S:3.1es F~;3_te ()f Ta;.i Tax Due TllE.>reon p 3 1. 3.~. ;.. 5� 46. 5.~~ oot, 22 Le::s: All�)\i.,t;;}bl>& Ta~;: Credit ,:::~,2.71 T::J.x Due p '}..3� 76.69::.. 62 Le:::::: T~n~ f>;::lid p 1.::!,9.:)66.3(:!, 4}. �:~,4f1 � ~.�::~ i�.d�:i: 2o::.;; Intere.:::t fr.::onl 4-2 1-/::.c. tc� 9-2 1-69 C�:::.mpromL::e pen3.lty TOTAL AMOUNT DUE AND COLLECTIBLE p
DECISIO, .. - C.T.A. CASE NO. 4721 -' 1991, re.spondent rendere-d her de-cision de-nying the protest for .--~'-T1��.�::::.f-i.-i1;A-.-t.1.. .-�--�i�IT inr�....-��~�� �rn;:..... tax but t11e c�ri~;dnal deficiencv� sales tax �-t I (.<l_.FPCES) c�n it-'=: purchases t-,�:-:�,(-.��;:�-:�:.1''\l.:-:�:�,.d.... 1-'��'l ~ !n�';:�:-�:.t~�r'tll_". ,.�--�)t'J.-P-� !' .---~-,+J>.j1 F..�-:�,i~-�--J..qJ-�:��:-��.r�\i;r f�:-,�.. _1(_i_t_{_-}_ Hence, tlw in'=:t:mt petitkm filed on� Ivlai"ch .3.. 1992, tt"�,.::. t�:=� t-1..--;:::.11-~; t1�.---,r-1 ,.-.,!- ,--1.:::. fl. ,.-.1� .::::.r-, .�-.�--i~T -i~.t�1r�......-��-,�t�r��.;i.::�:-�. t�=n-' _..~_,.~,."" :=1 !"1��.-+i d�-;::�-:�.t�l�,�-..-1� .�:-�:::.�!�,�,---�-I~! �c-:��:-:�,.1.i. ;�:-:�:.��-:�' .V_..,.,'..~. r~ �-��- ..1. �-� ��� J. ... :_._ �-� �-� -� �-�- .t. �- �-+ �-� - �-� �-� � �-- is li::Jbl<?. t�:) p:3_y defid<?.tY:y in�:::orne tax in the ::nnount of r1_�..c_-,.c_�,.:._:.:.:_.�c._�,c�tI��.,..-:.�:.:;.Lr�.t�. t'C._�..�_:�.1._1,_.:�:-,-.--���-j� i'_.;.U., t�;._:...c_,�r.�,.�_.��,1t--.(l-;-�:.!-)�-t� '--~'�,=--f��-:��::.ll�-r_��ct� n._;.:-:.:,.t._'f.1-1..-'���--�.-'t"l�.-:-:�:�:.t1-;!-1 t�t.-',.<d-:.:-. .�_:.�t"_t!~!-! (.'-!' " f :_1 ..L p-s-tEt.lty. tl-, .-. .., F' 1 r- .-...-, r� .-. ~� l.~ 0. r�,-!_�r�.�_":�j_l...t.."I"!~� r.)�...f..-~ ~ .0.,.1~1-'-�-l� . C) ' {��-j� JC)' ...:). .1.. () (; 't='.t-' t::;"c._�.t-::-:-r-tt-1� ' A�.}~;=f, 1.!l"lf-' .-. t-r� !....-+l�-n�.t.-.1-� c� ~r.--1 ._.! �� )'.)l. -� ��-� �._.. (:ompensating taxes paid on v;:J.rious import.:ltic�n of machinery �-r- �-r- t-:-.1tlr�-�l ;�-:�:[:....--Jl.l'l.r�-r-'�t�r�it:rt-Jt, �l.t... r\f'.-.---.1.:,:.1.,.,�-=.,��-=.1� �1-1-;�:-:�:.'��-�1 �~:,.c._-. fl� .�l�~/:-:.:(j �-:-t.c_c..-_-,t-:'-t----=-~� J) 1�) -l~� Lr_-.f-t:-;!�"I_.t.t...i.s.(,! 1(:? . t�-1� �;1::-:-. (._�.f."_.'�!}tO-��:-:�::.�t1�t't'1�--)�t"l ---f 1-..'.... !-;.:_:.:._.c, !r-,�-�'-..�'1-11--.-'l:7r-r1�t-� t-�r1�-�J:.t-� �c--�1't-1(.'_�;.:.:_:.. r--���;�:-�::.tl't-t�",�,,_t!--;1::-:-.1- r��---�':-.'�r!-���t''t-�:--�-f��ll'ry....:.:.,,-'-�-1 tl.�lt'c..�.. 105
DE..DSIOi., - C.T.A. CA..SE NO. 4721 - Page 4 - t� .:�':�.�t��"-f�l�rJ-1�r't~l�it:':�'t�1t_..t.iri�o::.:-". C._.�,�:-�.�.t"!".'i=.-"..'��.-.�.:-!!. "t�!-L��.�J�t�� tL-'.'=.-". '��.�ip�-�.'��-�l1--J'��-���t_.p._..��._�l ��.J��J-��lt�t. �l�:,:-:.,1t}.t. .:-�,..�;:--' .d- ..t�t .-:.��,�'i;r;.-J�'=��"�1�1-C.���p~. In ;::v:lditi�:)n_. the BIR has is:,:;ued BIR 1-1t�-:� :.t�--�~1.1.1-1.�.--l.�:.�:.r� t.1� 1A�~ ,-. 1r,..r�.-.�-,�~.�,,1�c��-1������-�'�r�1 �-� !- �~~'�~'��'(\�' ��=.�.tr�1��.�.l r�n�-�l�t��)h.-J.:-:�c--� ����l�tt..:.:....-�.�.! tL- , 1/ � 1-����A�.� tt.�.t1.��..�--��,t1<"::'-�t� J t.-��, �v � 1. Section _3.0((:) of tlle 1�)6 7 T3X Code: -sECTION 30. -..:-- ":7 -..:r- ~ .. 44 .C.a., (c) r:a.x'3s. - ( l) In general - T:lxes paid �::.r a(:crued ~A~it.hin Uw t::G�m.ble v� ear in -:::.::mnect.ion V�lith the. t3.iq:�.;:~.y�e.r's profe.s:sion, tn.lde or business, t � A .�. ,t;.71.;-"-��r~��r--��-�� Title.,; r r,_'F,_.. .�:i 1.'L,-�-.--�'-�'!11�t:-:.!_, -�~.-,~..:~.. 1� !,..}, t��1-r�l� t--~=� . ., r1 �:t. ~1._.. A�.�-i�:�..-~_�-1-7-.--~-~= !--) 1�� '��-��r�1� t-�-�=�� .,' t:::.,_T,::.�=: ~~-\.&.~�-� �-� .i..n1rur��1� ��=-� �--,~::�.-�..-�..1+ t~---~l~r :�-:�l._n.. t'-l� -1t__�)r�-1�t�.F1' ..-lr� 1 qr� ~i ' f.-...-. l..t. -.~...l��;:=r,r�1 .�-.�-.-,.�--�-,..,!.lJt. ��-��tr-1~r�-~ 'J' '-� but this deduction ~tr3.11 be a.llc�~hTHl in the case of a r1..-1t t-�~=-~-.:....,:-arJ)-��C;;..,Tjrt=.;.-.t� ~.'\~'1�1,.-....., (jf-)�-(�::�,..�1".:')� - �-� -� t=l ��J::1�~,.111�f~l;r 1�1�1 111�.--~. t�;�:-:�;...t.n._.t�!-1 1�1..i,�._::. d~~;ire to llEf'iiB- to amr extB-nt t11e. b~twfits of ..-�t�p.,.�lft�=� ' ��-� ._. .. �- .nr-��~~-1-t��~-=--~::;o:,t��'-~�1rn�1�1 r-::'1 ;��,f t.t.-.J11��=._�, �-=-� L�'i.t��.�=�-�:>... =._.>-tt..l...(l!l f\.t-t.:...:. .l~:,=.t...t..it�lcn~ t�,.-., l ...... "1. �-�' _. .... .. 1 {�,f r�..-�,t"Al.C'!-1 �,.-�,t- t:-.~.;;::.�=� (/l'11�ltt�i;:::.�:��~�� �-�"" -~:J..i..:..�...- �-� .... --� .J. �-� ;~ �-� �-� 1_._ �-� .L �-� �-� ... (C) E::::t~ t.e and gift tJ:::e::;_; 106
DECISIL...j. - C.TJ\.. CAJ~ NO. 4721 - Page 5 - (D) T:::mf.-s ::Jsse::sed a.gainst h>>Jl bendits of a. tind tending to incro&ase tlH v::;Juo& c�f tll>::> property ::1s:::e:::�::ed: :::1.n d (E) Eledric energy consumption tax impoE:ed (_�� y~:' r p,=i (~":-i�-��:-�� IJ.>:'-,�1� �;~�lt�t.-,:\l_1.. -i':-�-�1:11_, '"'�t��lio~ . -~ (, � - .... �-� . _.t �--� 2. Se(:t.ion .:)CI (.lf Eevenue Eegulations Nr). 2: -SEC <..1-tl Tax-es in ge..oeral - A; :j_ go&neral rule, t:txe::: are deductible Tvvit.h tlw exception of those v.ritil resJ.:>ed. to 'i..Vhich the lav.r does not permit d<?.(lU(:tit:)tl. Z i~ X. ImJ::n.xt. �:tuties paid to t.lle proper custom:3 r-� �-- ..- �-� -� -.- �-� �� . ,--,1-fl.( -~� .::.r-:: ::1 t�1���l !~--,�1�-1�-��-:�J:.i!lA-.��:�-:���:-�'.. (�-1� !�-Y� �-��11--- r,�=l t1�<"1!1 11�r��,::.t�~.-.-:'�,::. rn-� t � i� ~�r1'l.=�:->�Cc).'-<-=->-' �--��-� �-� �� --..!.. --� A�~�':a-.:a.-.��-��1� .;-;::, ::'J!"i(l r-� c�t�:t1"(ir. t.-.-~:y...;..:..:._,. c�--' �'-:�t-!"l,-�-.1 :r::.l.!"lt':It ,�--�-,-t�}}�A-� f t_�..:_t.~.�.:;:.:.-:.�.�c-;� ,.-.,!- I A~~,::.!-1' �-'��� .._ � �� �-� ._..__ - �J ... � .... tEJ.me or 1El.t.ure paid diro&ct.ly to tlw Gov&rnnlo&nt �:::.f the Philippine.::: or to ;:my politic:::1.l :::ubdivision therec{. are dedudit.le. T.lJ& H-�lJI(i '{.:7~l?S" JJJ.>f:'.:YJs� t~?.:;:..p;_;;- ~.f~t~~-~[}..p..t� ell}(/ .t.l-(1 (/.~-~-ill(�,~t{J.t1s- :..-;:/1-(,i.l.l(f _{-).f-1 .:"FJ�~l(' !--(5f'.(i .i'{)J- (:?l}J.(;l!.t} t.:..;� 1--~r~~-~.ps:-&.t} tJ~fJ.f.:�� Jj'Jt?.l:&s-~ s�llJ{~:/1\:-?/~:-:&:. ('.Jr ~D-fll.l~?/tf&:..-;- JJ:.lf~f~7&1Jt t~_., -~�ie.J~~ff}.-:_lltt?.l.lt"~.;-~ ~{ :i{ ~-{_ t1 "T1��;:::. ( (i' te- l ..... .... 'L�l,=�-�:t�.,.-...,t-.r.."l ... L�1t....1� .:..:.:.;..�_:�, r.r--.��\:.,�.11, � ,.-l t.~l r :.:C>.\ ,....-...,...-..,L!��r�-1�n:._:-\ �r�1~I;r ....-..-,1�1 1. .._. .... irnport::1.ti�:::.n �)f one ( 1) unit 197::. For.J LTD-4 door :;edan. t..:. l::u:::> u::;ed in t11e in::;pect.ion ()f its prc�jed.. <-Jr<?. U.tLd e.r :-.:.ect.'.1on .y- _.-n..'c.�!, .:! e.::.i. u.c l:_-."1Jf=:1�ke ~ n:m1 L'tS gross l. !K(:.tne. 1 ,-,t t1��,::. � .1. .�. l-..� 1.l.::-.-;~..a;.-,-~�,�-,-,�.-�1-.+:�.-::�. ::_1__�_=__: 1.1_i"1l.r.-,ll�;.�:.:..Lt�1---P-�':l.��-l..t�,�-::�..,j t~--,-u" � :_::;p__ ,_�:t_.l�,:_)!",t. T:=i? F'~;�:-:�.c;=.-�1�-1�}\�-;�- t.1-�,..-). 11....:_:-.. I t-1 ..--r-.r-�lA ___ ..,.:. ___ �-� J. �-� "In reply tlJ.erE:-t(\ I 1Et':72 t1"1e 11::)!}:)!" t-::. inform ycu. that f�)r incdne tax purpo:::e.s.. t:J.x<?.�:: }>lid ,:=:�r tl--1,::. 1.!1 (f1!"t!lPr��th",t1 t�=i'-!':Jt-,1,::. -~i,.-.,.-.!-'14.-�l ~:.!l�H-Il�t-1 ~,-.ritkl 1...., �.,� '�' '-�� '.,' '� II .,�.:.- .:.. �.,�l. '�' t- '�' � .~.,. .:..<&.1-, 'l:!,:'�:'>�..�.�:,.Jt. � '�" '�' ... '�" '.,� �� �.,� - I I 1.. .,�i the t::c:{pa.yer�s trade or business ;;:.,r.s- deductible 1)Uf'3UJ.nt. t) Section ~ ;:,O(.c .H. 1) of tho& T::tx Code as ' ~ a.me.nded. (:::ee al:;o Sec dO, Rev. Re.g�:;_ No. 2) Such fr<��m its 107
DEOSION- C.TA. CASE NO. 4721 - Pageb- <i'J:ut-s-rly gr��-:-:: tn�:~.-:�m.::-. :::nell bu:::int.-::s t=Jxe-:; 'i ~>)tEd:;ting ;>f the ::_idV::l.11C9 -;aJ% ta.x p:::dd en the I 1mpc-rted rav? rn:::1t.erL::l.l:; used in tli.e n>:111uf::1d.ure (:.f it:: fini'.::hed pL<lU.�::ts a::: �\��.7>?.11 a::: t11e :::ale; t.:::Ge::: paid t)!l t.lie ::::::dd rini:::lleJ prCd 1JC~S i..-,;hi<::l'i .:t.re �::�)l'J by it .JiJring tlle t::ca.t�ls- quarter. (Sec..:::�~�-� T3.Z Cc..:le). ~�ik�rec�'ler. mating �;udl declucU.:::�n v,rould not i!r:l�:::>l7e :3. �::hange in E!�:�>:)1J.1iting rneth(!d rer:luiring the prior con:::ent of the Commi::s1-:::�ner oi Interna.l Revenue�� Ev�en assuming tha.t the CEtpitalized Custr:)nls Dutie; and item in comJ. )UtitN�-� ta.x:j_ble inc�)me f.:x the g-i';,;en v" ea.r. i p�, nr-(:�.t� t-�;-:.c-i -ri-.,. ;:--1� c-1�11. !"1P� .!..;.,, ;:-:1�1�1c-l ;:-:.(~11-1�-i nr~t��r-~.. ;:�.:.:...r1-t c�;:-:i�!"1!.1�0t�. :=--�t t�. t-.l�,-A-� �:-:-::::-:-1.af-'1''"l..~. t.1� !l"lt;;.�" _ _ J. ... paid on l�rI�l�1rY)�r+�.� a.nd ' �:>tl�,�)tl . t.l."..�.tA�-�t"A�-�;���-,�+!h,._~. ;tr !"I�l,:�:-:�.��.::.>1.+! ."..;�r~� n f.-..:. ,~l,:::.f'!�,:::.,.-.1� �-� A~-q:;>=>t}�::::A -'"~'f-:l�t."A���:-::.>J. �{-l ;�-���,'~.�'-�A!" t�t.��il,::�:-�. 11'!".A... f�-��r!� ._... �-� ..., �-� --� ,_{_ -- �-� a..a. -� .... o,.,r �..r H-lA 1. 1.�.1 �-� r�J�..�..,'C.-.1..,...-..1~~1;.-t"t-��A~t",1=l 1��1-~"1l-f�'o...(.�,t�t-,�:�:-:�.;.��fl.. Tl"I...A�-� !"l-l�ll.l"!C;::.i-"~ ...�...l.t-��A-:� r�-l [..Y.� ';:7 .r[-�'.A�-� t-l�'l-'-1� �,�--��,t'lA- !' !"A�..� fA.�.!"C..... t..t..�.�..,. import:J.tic�n of El.Tvv rnaterials to be used in the rnanufactu.re of finisbed products a.nd not to c::1.p1t::tl assets used t�y pet.it.kmer in thP. rl.-.�t....i'-:- o.(+iJ--v-ti-;--:-r.t.�l i"...:>!. !--it�1+-=--:r'lP�- .(-l rn�r-(:n-��-.i.l1-C�-t:-::-;. _... _- Cur inu::.n1e. ta.x st::1.tute i:; patterned 3fter the Internal the TJnited St::1.tes interpreting. as 'Hell :::1.:=: the ruling:; �:::.f t11e pro.per 108
DECISION- CT.A. CASE NO. 4tl1 -Page?- ,�..�.,!�!��i�,--��1�.:�~.,J�.�.=.: 1�1-1 ,-:.-,�t1�!�,-.-� ,!�-..--1��.r1fo_-,-_, t.1���;�:�:-:�..1�!. 1�1��,,.-,�.�--. n�al.::.:... t-~.v �c-�:t���J:tn...t_.,.:_:..:,. �h�:.~J.\,!.A, [--��.�.:�::�.-,�����111l�.�_.~J~- !-.v.-lft�._..:.:,:. 'i ��'�'��' I in t11e Philippines. (Wise & Co. v. Meer, 44 O.G. No. 12, p. 4817; Madrigalv. Raffe-rty & Concepcion, 38 Phil. 614; Zamora v. Collector, L-15290, 15280; cited by TOMAS P. MATIC, JR., Income Taxation in the Philippines, 1979 Ed., p. 67.) Our Se�d.ion <:;o of Eevenue Re!u2"u.lations No. 2 ~Nas 1T1�1�---1� that Jr.)�,_�:1t, t-<�--=�-.>--t"tl�A-����-��l:�..:.;,�t-t-A��-�t-� r-'�'r�1.:-.:_:.. H�--� t�l1�t-.��:--.-,���-l �'-=':'.-..t:_-1:, t.�--t~:f�.=_�: Jt.�-r:�:-:.o-.--�Jt,l_1�_:t-t��'�-��)rf�.c_-, 1�-'l 1 '�-� 1 r_-.-��rf�,_-.t~~,''1�r._�-t._A.c,_�, � t. -� "1�1!�1tr-�-�'�,�-���,r�'t�� ,�--�,r� t.�.,:..-_t.,r�1�1�f ��..�.i1-1t'1�'�'-:;�:-:'.._:�, r-����:-��1. �-�-..1 t.�J.�_�.t t..�l�1"�...' f-�.'�t��I�.,�_�,�rI.-.JA... r� r'.�J"'Jl_c,�.--Jt.�-'�.-�.,Ltl�1-�=-'� �...�_.,�ff1.I'.-_~--~r���=-�'.r '':=,\"n.�._�l 1�!�1�t-.��:~�:-,rr�Y�-:-~l .r.;.:-.;, ~.A.. !"i-1��1�A.� ,--.�-�-~,--1-.~�l-A� .�.---�-t��,--�~!-c._:. �' ~-,.<~!A.t..�.:::-�. r�-l+A�-�r�}� lV__-�.t,.l-��t-~.--,J....p�-�. ::,.:- t---~~-�y-~p��.-�c---~ 1�r�r�lrr...r�-,~c-�-;~:�:-:�..�-d� .~......,.',;r ._._._, .:._::.. v��rr-���.�.-:�::.t��� �.-:���;-::�.��-:�� (._�.,t� t�-t-~L~- tL-.,1-''��c-���i�1�.�-.-:-::-..-:����=-�� t._i. !" t.1. ��L.:�:�-:�. ,.-..-,c�t �"l!. .�:_, J�t.t��r�.�.l.;.;_,.c._-. ..._--.r� t.r"1�A,t�l ;�..-.~~1-.:...,.,_.t.�1�.r."ll..._:�.,:.:,;. -._� ._. . ._ � �- ��-� wA. be sep;:.1.rately deducted The option referred to the .r&tU..tJ~ deduction for inlD� �:)rt dutie~: tn the treatrnent of such dutie-:: ')11 the bCn)l�:s a.s ((:.::t (.{ invent(::.ry'." (MERTENS, Law {)fl Federal Income Taxation, Vol. 5. S 27.25, Chap. 27 - Page 53-> Even :3::=~:uming :::;s' petitvmer c:lairns ttt::Jt a re1.<er::::~tl ~)f the depreda.t.ion charge i::; added b:::v:k t~::- inccme bef()r-e- the ,-,1� 1- ,�---�-�-;�-1-,��.I.-1i_f."�-J��l"t�'=-�;�t-l��.-��.-,�I��1. -:.� 1. t�1,-.,-.,rf-1A lit�l f;'�t�t�,-, ,-.. t~-iA �.�J. �-� .1. -:..��.�- t:~�Y t.�tL�l�..~.. 1�.� .1..1._ �� � y�.:::.r�:-.tt�;~ .��.-�+l ;�:->��:-=� !t"!11�!�1;~o�c-'-.��1, _..��_ .............. ��� �---�........ ,_.... r�1 r'�1�=-tr! ':�:-�)�.-v"-��(11I'_1_1��t�A�.� .--."l1.t�"l 10?7 Al_!_ ;:,,�-t ir'�',A�~� t-t�� t1. (;flAt� ,-.,.-.,t�1c�i h1' t�;:.,�l1l �-� '� ��� .._) I . T ~ �-� �-� ~ .--!Ar�-~, ~;r j. .�� �- (Atl ._. .... �;.� ..._, -� ..... - �.�.;. - ._.... �- �- -� fo.� / - � �. ��� ._.... f�:)r the. V�i A....._'i..t..". 19d7 109 )
DECISIO~- C.TA. CASE NO. 4721 - PageS- 1�..:l�:=�)- 7 tl-...,1;.1' r�l:=-tt. tY�1� t�ro �=~ .�-�-.l�.:.::.�,..+-i]�J....-�-.�'f"�.1..�---�--.,1p. 1 �-� -�� 1.1.! .l i=t '-� r-�,etl� r� t::J 19E;7 the ar.nount of - - t-1'(->1.�'~.: f1' (�1� t-_�1�-~� J. �-� ~��t�".!j. .,...-�"-��llY �C--:"~-1� 1~�-�c�:-� -~--..~&-4!. r�(~�f" in ... F:. 11 r-�r� �-.t.::.c-t t �l tl�.:::. !"t.:::.r� r�.::.,�llJ<�c.. r� -~. ._.' J.,�,.!..=.~..(�(iI'�'-�')�-�;�:" ~ ,-J~. .. ( ..�~��-'�� 1.",'~--':����-=�' t"t'l~.�,�-.�.l .' !:�;�'..c,�;r!��,"(��' �r���f�(�l.�~�t��! , ����. �-��v�...... !�..� J.J. ������ s �.� -.- .o-....tI��Lt-"ilJ.t"l. r�'' t...-.-)� F) 1(=j��'-)', __�j_.. 1''-)' ..(..) .-_~!, ,�..-�..,......,1.!..,[-'.-tJ..t...~.. .�.j .�_:j. . fr��tl(\1,\T'<C�-.�.� {�.[i . .�-:.:.:��=.)- 7I�' Lt:;Jp�.� !�.�:.:,:.,.�-,.,) "Net Taxable Sales 1 f, c. " n.t" .�_:-) 7 -~� Rate of Ta:x t�1.._, ;'�;)?(C.!I J '�' _}.(}.:~:1. Tax Due T1Hre�:)n .rrf.. Le-::s: A11�Y/la.ble Tax Credit 10% T::tx Due f> 2:.1 . 2(;J,3)72(!_~)0 Le~:s: T:::r::-: Pa.id Deficie-ncy Tax 22,()('{).{)';12.71 Add: 2::.:;g: Surch:3rge p 9,2f�9,{)7.::,..:~.7 us q 7 -~.07.44 102_.~>66. 4.3 2C:.641.60 Add: 2 o::.; Inter~:::t.Jrc�rn 4-2 1-f�f) to 10-21-90 64 104.00 TOTAL TAX DUEt~ COLLETLE:.LE :p 192.?.12.(:r_�;; =================~ H.- FF' d.T'�~'1�1�1;,:.:.,:..:-=.. t���:1-.t�l t.�.'�;�;'1.�� 1ll-.1�.i.��~�� -� �-~ t-.�:J.~'�:~. ~�.�'.~,;'',.'�;;t' �I�lr1�.!t1.��1�.�)1�l 1��.}�1� ,.:..u..:.l,.l�'.;-;'...;-:.. t�J��.l���-:.~. -�.��t.�.c... t�.(�.! t.~-i�lt:~::' 11 J. � 1���=-1��--�=--�n.�:.:.�(~l 1'�(.�~:-:-1-��=-�� r.l.11-�.:�:.�. t-(���.,� t1-��1.:-:..�. ~�.r,t:.�...--�-,�1�1~�.,.�.-..�J�t1_�_=._-, t...�.r:.-1�.~y.~ ~I--...-,1. 1 11��i �1cc�.��=-�� 1�1��1-:-:�1- (1�..~- ~J..-.. .lv r:-::e-t�t=1-_.1�1.1 J. r�,:::,�=:lllt?>tl q._j. ~-��r}-.!.r'��i1'~t...��:.�_. ~.��a,rl�l1i�(.��~!�l tl�l,c, i't;.:_; .�.._. �-� ����� .. 1'1�1� .�. ._. t�li��:._�'.:._'i_ll(i �,,-..;;,,�;:�:-�t-!"1�.(.�.;.:.., (._.�1/ .~.-.:�-I�V-�� (.!"f>.. (.A1- . 1l0
DECISIL--�- C.T .A. CASE NO. 4121 - Page9- Petitioner r:::redited fn::�nl its sales tax allovred only the sum of P22,(H)<3,852.71, thus the balance of J I :P 12,'\734.70 ~.~las disalk:rwed as a dedu.r:::tion, itf?mized as foll(iWS: 'Nant.er (J~>hilippines) Incorpr:)rated - 19f.7 ':,.-�1'1;:::.,.-inl;:::.- f..l..\.TI;::�J:.t� I ..E1'l"(�,�-t�"l;::.:_..(�.)1J-��=�--' T�=�1-�'"-':.~. t~--.... ,l'lll't�lo-_.c.._-. r�.�Ll'=�'-l�t'�!�;::v:. 1.'.l.1LT ,-.�..-..;�:-:�:.r�t-_:.z-..J1. '1-1 �C;J ]J�nI,:n" }I;."i';:::....+,. .1��--:-a-. t.J ..... �-- ._ - ._. . SUF'F'LIEP.S COST TAX ALLO~.�lAP.LE ItiSALLO~~TABLE REASONS FOR :BILLED H3ALL o-r.uAlKE 1 Standard F'1 . 1:32.00 Contr:~dor's Ta:{ F'l::tstic �::o:cp. P32_. 21 8. 00 F' 1. 18 2.00 Bi11it�~.s 2. Fiot::dlex 284.2? O~"LY 1.5�~t ig (or�p. F'.tdls. 2.. 842.6:5 a11o','�'~J:.l!? . .b~?it~ sttpp1i>?rs (G>?nt<ra1 tf-:-:cet.,mdis~} Inc. 626.21 :H ~i.ll 31 ~i.l1 - do - - dcr - 4. f'E-:~�:E- f'E-1'l 1.. 758.45 852.84 905.61 - d.r) - E:ntl?rprises 56. 856.45 - �iO - 5 coriii.3 Sa1t>s 3!;;0,.429.76 11 . 66q_60 \706.45 5. 96:3.15 6. F:cc�nUine- Lit�~.f::a~J? .- Inc. 7_.602.. 6:~;0.70 228.. 078.92114.. 039.46 7. A~_ana �2i:cc1e 983.84 Ef1t ... It�tc~. 65. 922.78 :::. iJrl:slo Enf.. 59.. 902.54 5.. 957.46 398.54 i.-053. 92 P128, 7~4.70 �8.n investiq�-�a.tion conducted bv" tile examiner reveal:; tllat 111 /
DELJSION- C.TA. CASE NO. 4121 - Page 10 - ._.a �C-J1. 1.::.:_:.;.:�:;,.:.:.,.,..-_j. t.<.1-.,-:..1~.t.- .�.-��.��.it�l/~~ ~.....-,�,...,.1�,:-:�,t.:-::.'_. c��1��t:�::�'-�:�� ��..�1�!� H--.,!;ll�"t::�:'t�c._�. t_-.:_:.:_..~.~~ pa� .�l-(1 ..-_.,..-:.!.�11h.,_.:,_,. ,-.-��.��r..e_.:�.._��lt".,te�.�j Tax t:redjf. - (a) Credit.:Jble Taxes: - i",nY s::-~�:1::;.:?., :::;:}h::.::; (::.r mill.:?.r'~; tax paid und-2.r Tt.t1.:.::. tt�� T{fJ.l.�:~�.::�-.� T' r ~-!Vi 'J k� ,.-.,1�1 .. -�~ �.� l~;r , ,�..-�,if :-..--~~�-1>=> ��� ,�-..-+l,�.����-,rr�l.-.:�::�-.'�:1-_~.1, ,.-.,.,.,:_~_ 1 - "/ ,_1, �- ��� .A.L�-� �-� -.� �� �-� .� l, i-' nr����,(l' ,��,r� ,�,tnt�,;;:..,�t �l�r�J�.�.~J t't-,- r,(�,t�r� -11!"" 'J t"� 1.J'.l��.~J. '�-� -� '-'.- ._, '.. �' Tl�"' �l,��,,,_�....,.�,�;:._:...�_:���._:,.,;�-;�:.��,-�l .. I�' �-�� �- '-1~(._'.A._.i."_l �., ?>(l _ .._.._ �t��'�~'�i~., /'IT J.! r��� ., 1�' t...}l'~-~J.t.�-'7'!;�, �..i...:~.. !! -=-�.. lr)�':=-.~1��t-�.. :'1:.'�.�.�./-......~,-=�---=��-'�-') l ��1�' !�,.)'t-� tl~~ .tL" ...:;,. ,_ 1___ f::! 1" 1+1. '�) '- "11 )'..-l: .... 1 � � / f- � �1�.,- � �1 � �1 tl�- rt � f � r 1 !.C r)_,_1 !;:,_~:;~:._ () t� 1�11�1� )=)~ ..-~~~ tt--'nl .-lt' 1I-l;.:1..,!l_l_1_!df.-i._�:tp��-�.t�~� !' ~").tL� �r�,t,-, ,.-�..��-�-.,-.l-lv~,t�:-:�:t'��..::_�.i���..�.�-�.t1- .!. ........� ��.�..�.�t- _1�11� t�'.�"...'!-1,..�i't�::�:'��.�. l t_(.�._) t���--~���.t�r!-1 r-_�.�.-._:tJ�t_. (�.��f ��:-::�.+-�~1'/' 1��,,:::. . 1 1-,.-.,t- �1�1!-1�'��-:;�J�-j;:.�:..;-�~,lJ. f.��)!�,..�-� .�,~,-'."--ln� �r-��t-� -~� r-~-�:1-�1?'>�' ���1"1:~11 -� �-� '�-'.l�,:,:_,.,���-ll'j-,�:-:��:-.�,.-�-1 t'=1..Cc_',:�-:�.l1.1."..l..d... .;) �-� the sa.le::: t:c~ on ;;t:,h_egricourltiu'2�-r�'ci:ntlal :;:;;::1.le of the finislwd product, excr2.-pt products: .I~t~or'./(/-:?(/ .b:(�H-::..;.v&l: T11at t1'1e arw,::.unt �:::.f :;::;::J.le::; taz ;:::.11 .::l.:�me::tica11y pPn::l"L;::ised ra_,,...,r n13.teriai_ p;3_rt or acce:::sory_. i::; :::eparately indic3.ted in the sa1e:3 invoice. . In the ca:;e of DlJ.f(:ha:;;;. c�f ra':..>l mat;;.rials.. r-)arts c:md a.cce::sorie::: f)v a m:::mu.fadu.rer frorn a du.lv regi:::tered and ac.-:':redited dealer, the amount of tax' passe(! on tf.) t11e dealer as v.rell :3.::: tlle sale::; t3.X on subsequent ::;;:J.le. if irKlica.ted as sepa.ra.te i~.ems in t11e de;:J.ler's sa.les invoice sllall be allov�.re�:.:l as credits 3.gain::;t the :::=::,_le::; t::.u~ due ('fl the finished product. �~'1.- n/~� c._-~_..._�.l .~.~.~:l..t��l�..-...'.:�;:.' :.a..-.. 1�f�::�:'.c_�-'�t��:J..�-:~.. f.-"�=c.l.l�.._��1 '.�-.-'t-i l.Hl-f.-lC.' .rt�e'�:��.'���j .~:.t�tJ.-.,_�-.�1.-:..:..~-. �;ha.11 bE> a.lh)'�'�lE>.-:i :Js (~:r~?dits ag::tinst thE> sa.l.s-�; tax due c�n the origina.i �::::Jl<:> of '3U(:h irnported article." The cr>?.dit of c.-::.ntrac:tor ::: tax V�ras not pro~lided t1"1erein. Fo11o~,q1ng tlw a.(cepted prindple ,.,A statutc�rv� construction e.xp.r~ssio ll.IJius est e�..:llls.it? a1t~ri11s "V�lhat. is not included is deerf1ed e::~du.ded", the sanw (:annot. be a1lov.red as a credit from the sales tax. 112 __/ ..
DECLq01~- C.TA. CASE NO. 4721 - Page 11 - t:lx 1�.~?-a.s billed - ~;epara.telv a.s a SH_:.;::tra.te item in the invoice. Thus,� 1 ' .~_~c-r-,�.._-..,�1-�1-1r�_. c���t- t,t1-1.:�.:_:.. t���=--�~.�~-~' �c-�-1t1-1�ft_�.�e�.�.�_�1 t-����-�� 1�._t. ..,,...,t�,t1tl..._~, l-l� t_. 1-I��:':.:>~.11�1-16~~ t_�..�._�.. ����-�1v��� fl-l�rt-h� "��'~t� ��1��� z�;::. .-. !- ;-r� [Ilf.'ll t�-t t1� .-,1�1c: ._. . } } - � .....: ...� 1,_. �-� t.t...�_�.f f... !:::" t..!:.:-;.! t"l-!"11.11t':�:" t.1� �1 f'':�:! .o.:.T,. !"!"!,;)�]]�1-l�t..- t.l.."t~'� tl"tO::.!"i �-�'�..�' ,1 �-� �..� tl�!;::. rn��11-� t�nr�r� ��)c-~-'=:'_:�'1 ""' �-� ~>f the law is ;:.Khie,led. The reo)urse of the q�-�overnrnent in case t�- r-� ., tl- .-. .-..-. .-1 �1 -. r�r- -. r� .-. t' r� .� i~ '�..-��..' ec��t_. c� .d.l"?:aT. ' ,=~t,t.:...,l.._: 1'-...r t_. ) { } .1� �... t~-) P :..1.11~" c._�,J-l�rr.�.'1r.J11�;~:: 1l !._':;:~d.l.:...:...r� 1��c-�' t..,_-...} ca/'�.-J. 1 "t�t-����1 ,-,f Atlas tJ�e:. �:-~��.i-:),'.~�t.:>1.11.,cj�t... t�t-�1.1::�.:.... .C_t JJrn��rL'�l�l�.o:.:...t� l/;1._ .:.:...,;�:=:l-l..._:.:.t-." Po.:_.:.t..t�.t1...�,�-..t,tlo:�.:r.t� '-" f::f:�.. 1�..� ,.�_-.�,_�:1:.-._c~��,-::�. ._. Fertilizer Corp_ v_ Commissioner. 66 SCRA 165, as f(;llo~.,ls: "To repeat the rnain issue in the c:3.se a.t b:3.r is Vllwther the i!.~FC is entitled under the Tax Code to d~duct t.lle r�urc11a::::e cost i)f t11e pyrite it used as i!-cv�:-.-r~dient in its rn:3.nufacture (.if fertilizer f(�r the purpose of .:))mpu.ting the sales tax it must pay on its sales of fertilizer. In expounding their respe(:t.ive posith:ms on this issue, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue and the Court of Tax Appeals appear to have be-n confused by their obses:::ional pre(:.cc:upaUon v..rith tl1e JJJ.(Jd&.t.ll.:11rnattf2r of V�lhether >)f not the ACivlDC had paid a sales tax c�n the pyrite 113 ) / / _/
DECT5I01 ... - C.TA. C~'\E NO. 4121 - Page 12 - it. h::1d sc�ld t.::! t.he AFC: Uwy failed to t:::1ke �::Iue '::tc�ct c�f the org;:.mio::: relati�)n�::hip ::unr::�ng the pE>rtinent �=�t�1d �-:�';-::.._�.�1�,t-fi.�t�_�.,t�l��:-�� �-�- �-- .ri�"�'�!,.��.�-.��~rl��.:_�.�lt_�.�,t�1��-:�� 'r.��,!f t�i��-1�1�-�::f ~l �=--t~v~ (._�.\�_.�,-.(l.~� 1�l..s-.,~:!��.��.�--,J:~;c-.� �~�-l .-ll��:::..--,��11�=:;::.(1', 1 1��,,.::.!�c.1� :-:-c.c_:t_.i.--.:..t�l-=_: t:~1rc.�=t(l~r �.�-'�"""'.,. L. �-',: .., .�.�. ,�..�,~J,!,_�. .�~.�f.(l �-,.�t�.:,.� '� - �.-�.� -��'- ...... ' 7 i 7 ',......, .~ -- "' [_�=,f:,_ - �- F�6-,i:., ::u1d U~<.(;::). a::: ~.~.re�li a-::;=} precs-pt. ;:pJ.it.s- t:;:,:::i�:: in tli<?. field �)f �::a.1e:: t;:J.Z<?:: Under S<?ction lf,t.(c), if t1lE~ .L.~...(l.-IDC v.,rzr:: t1w le�:see. (>i,-!JtlE:f �:::.r conce':;St�:)!Etire of the minera.l 1:3.nd irom V�lhicll it rem(>\led the nvrite that. it. had sc�1d tc� J. I the. ,<\FC, tlle.n it �;�\!:3.:::: &X&rr1 0t from f)aving :3.11V sales.1 'v f tax on its sale;:: of pyrite. .t..ny purch::1s&r - SU(h as the. AFC - of pyrite frorn t.l"ie i".CI�.,..mc rna.y de::iu�::t U1e f--�U!'(:llase (>/3t �A ::;1J.c11 pyrite. uw:le.r the. a.ut11�)rit;:r of Section 166-...-:\ Vlhkll pnY.rides 'T0lh.:;:.ne.ver ;:t_ tax-free product is utilized in the ma.nufacture or produdion of any article, in t11e deterrnination of the value of such finished article., the va.lue or ::;udl ta.x free. pr�:::.duct :::l"r::1.lll::.e. �Je.dude(l_,' "On the other h;::md. if the i-v:::rvmc v..ra.::, not qua.liiied for exemption frorn sales tax on it:: sales of py-rite under Section 1f,f,(c) (because. it v.ra.::; not tlie lessee. �:)Vmer or conce.ssiona.ire of the mineral land fr(:.m 9lhJch it rernoved the pyrite). then the AFC (or .c anv~ ot11er 1r~)Urclia.s>:>r of f.l,V. rite. fr�:::.tn tl1e. f�:)rnler)� ca.nnc.t. in'lOke. Se.cti<:)fl 1M:.-A a�:; t.lle lB-ga.l ;Ju.tll(:�rity f t11.::. t��t-:J� tll�' ��t� ��t� !.) '��~:i':�:';'-'.�:iJ-J�'���~��t�. l1-.1;,::~, .J' �~� :.1 ).) .... '�....�:-.)-:~:,+-�-� t) . ~ .rt~.�.'r}�l�t..,.).�:,;: 1..1_.- Ir).1_1.t..."r�'-�l1"o'�.:~:.,:':"'.'�--j fffcO�l!l'ollw t ht he3 tAtChlve!DlC~. . F. 'c H�)V�tev<er. it doe::; not thereb ve' (a purclw.. ser of pyrite fr�ATI th AClvlDC! is b;::J_rred from deducting th>::- pur(:l"r::lse cost of the. pyrite. from the. gross selling price c-f the. manuL:1.d.ured article (fe.rtilizer) sold by it. The �::ieductic�n can stilll::oe. m::v:le. but 1...1.w1er tlH a.ut.11ority ~.A Section 1g.(::. 1..1lhicll lT� )Htine.ntlv' reads: �x x x f'[(�ri:"l-&t~ TlEtt v-.rllere the a.rticles subject to ta.x under t.llis '::ection are rm:mufactured C�Ut c�f n1a tHLJl:; lite.v\~i:::e. subject. to t3.X under thi::: :;e.d.lc�n �=�r�1.-l C'-��'!!"lr..". l �._::.,:._:.......-.--t�l�.-�-i�!-1 ,�--.�,1-...tA�-� l"...ti...,.,\.1�!d..t...�..;::�.-,�-�1- '-\._...:_:. .1::';c:,.J-. i�1'�"hlr -fl1��-~,::. �' i ... �-� 114
DECT5Il.�1 � - ,. C.TA. CASE NO. 4721 - flage 13 - the. t()ta1 cost c.f �such materials.. as du.lv' established. slE1.li be deductible fn::on1 the gross :.:;elHng price or gross value m money of ::;uc:h manufactured articles.� Tlie i!}:)f(lina.te. attention p;::dd t�y t11e Commissioner of Internal Ee.v�Emue- ;:Hl(i the Court of T3.X ~Ll~ppe;:J.ls to the pos::;ibility tllat the iV]�.JDC did not Tr-)::J.rv ;:U1V SE:1.1e:=: t:Jx on its sales c�f r~vrite tc� tlH AFC , .. # bec�:)me:; rnore dearly .lfidl-n~o~s- V�lhen it is considered t.ll;:rt. funda.rnentally, tile s;:J.les t::tx 1::::: :3.n obligation of the seller and not of the buyer. T1"1e (\)tnmi::si�:)ner�::; rec>:)Urse is against the ACI��.iDC. ;:t.rd not ag;:J.in~;t the AFC_. if tlle� former did not pay a.ny _,. .o:'u"':�t:>1�~~,.�.=.� f.) 1 j~) "'/1'1-t.P��~. t...l...,lc��~. ... k'(' llll-110b ' 11 t.�..=C~-.'~ -~ '"' 1. t'-.�-=-� ..:~u-::>l,1,:;-:*.���-=�� t)-.�) �=~ ...:1--�=~�"-1'� . :':.. !.�.! .1'-i.J. 'J} :::.,. !-1.--i,::.t- t t~~�-1!-~:_1, ... <:',::..---t1� (111 t}�l,::. CAJ. r� I �:�J1 [ �l (�-'� ~-.. .�,,..t:::>.l.��=-�' 1�1-.�."'"1�t� ,..:..:~.4�.�..~.-,::.11-.1�..!. nt-� 1-1� �- .�. 1-r �-� ._. ,_.. ��� ..�J. ._. �-� 1{)[)(<::) �:)f the Tax C�YJe fn::rn1 payrnent of s;::~.les tax on its sales of pyrite." T'l!'rT' 1� t'd}� - 1-t-?!-:if-'t�?G- t-- j1._.�() t-~--~Hi <�.11� -,=-::311l�.'T\�\T�c- l.l-!<-.:e- 0�t- rr��, 1_. 1.~_�;..-~, . (_'J.l.�). _f-e- pt- ':-:,.6'tl' t..�ttlg e . . . 1�n tt��- (.._�.(..-.1�t1"'_. �:.1.l-_-.�.t.\�.~�.1-r��..:~. ~1�-d-.....,:�T~ LP:l1.111�1t�;n=,c�-��,. t.-t!l-- 1-~,--.=_�.-.f)<'rt�ll_.-l,'I.V."_t-lt._. T\.'Vy�~:,t.-.:-r t.-..)<-�t�t�t:,:-=.".(�~t... (_'.l.t...t'nrOr t..11.~., the original sale:; of finished product. This is bol:;tered by the fact that tlle sales tax, excise or miller's taxes are paid on "domestic:;::tlly m:3.nufactured. processe:;d, produced or imported nrvvT materials. part, acces:;orv or other article locally purchased ' ~ or imnort.E?d by the manu.f::i_durer". The Contractc�r�s tax is a tax p:~.id for the :::ale of servke::: by those persons enumerat.E?d in .1::":.e�\,��_t.�1,-.A-l 17, 't'_) (_�1) � t._l.��1-~- .. T~.:1.A (.�J.-,-(1-e. Tl�1�1,--:.- ~-_-1o-E:-?r.:�- 1-10t_. U .-).�1n� oA:;-t- p�e-t�,--.=--<-A-l,--:o. "�=-'l_l_b,l_''o�:;--<.�- t_. practice oi their professions. The contractor's tax not being included in the enumeration is therefore excluded. 115
DELI.SIO.t~- � C.T.A. CASE NO. 4721 - Page 14 - The relia.tK' of petiticn.;;-r in tl1e dt.ed �-� all ,.--~-.~.----,�!-f�i�1�r�,.:.:.-:.�:,l--,--..�1-���-~-11 ~-IYil_l���lt't. 1�c- 1~:1. J_l1C_._�,J_J__�".:1>. l r-����r~.�:t'.'t.�l��-~� .',-;-:-,~ �ja.t-f-1'."...;r1-1-'-:.; 'i'IP.�-!�"i�'�-�-I-��.-��;r�c�--1 t�_-J.._,. c--~-1-!t'ft... r.. i / �-� �.. .!' �-' ��..-...,!- 1r��.�...:-1.!�r�-� ,.._-...if t�.t� �lt::.:-:.' t.-�":>'�<��7~ c'-,1--1!"'��"1�. ."'!1' t(�_.._.. t.'.�!,1::-,.<-1z- ~�--��t�F-�='��_t..()�fYd !-:;-'-r��r=.�. (S 8" ' <.;A; ' Abad v - Court of Tax Appeals, L-20834. L-20903. October 19, 1966, 18 SCRA 374, 385; Commissioner of Internal Revenue v_ American Rubber Co., Inc., L-19667, November 2 9, 1966, 18 SCRA 853; Philippine Acetylene Co., Inc. v_ Commissioner of Internal Revenue,- L-19707, August 17, 1967, 20 SCRA 1056; Gil Hermanis v_ Hord, 10 Phil 2 1 lt:>c� to:�, 110 orr�,c-c� ll'��t - ~ V9..- ) 0 tt-,..,,._~l_C._�,,:_:_:.O�(-"l ...-_.J Tl-,..::. t-�.,:::.t' 1"1 1"1���1 C:�:< �-� -� (�)-1"1 .1 &. �� y C= �-��-'�-' ':=-�l �- �-�'-�� �-��-' ,...__ . . . . . . . . .� �-� t-l���".._"._-..c_,..._:_:..1. 1t�!-:l:;',' rr-'-t�_1..'-�.-.--.~ 1�!.-.,------lJp.�-.�-.��-l-,:�:�,-.�c�--� t�'-r� �l,::�-:�. t.--'.-.-���,-c_:-t-� (�-����f t�r��!:l�.:>t1-l-lf�~:1,_-._-. t-l�-l�!.-""�-'� -,_~._�t-1��'-1� i�-�-'l�J, ""�---� t�l�l~-.J;o..,.-_1 tl�..::. �"�'� t_-.:-J�,,~q:,�~v,-I:i ::�.dt- (�-�lf t�--~'-,'\�.���.~:��:-:�.�c��' Lit��ti.-..-�..) ��-~�--'�-�-��.�.-�'-�---'�-.-�,]1!l-�t~ 1�1-1 1��.�.le'.:�.t�,��:�:�.,�.t�!�-l-L�1�11_1J..t-1::n. -� 1��-� C�-'"~'ll�1t-,�n.:,� f.')1"1�.--�-�.,:�;',~. 11.1,1'.�:-:�- t_J '-' g-:::r�:xl-:: (American Rubber Co_ v _ Collector of Internal Revenue, 64 SCRA 569.) For sales t_ax purpo' se::::. the only (:onditic�n in order tc� be t1�1.::., ��:-�'��~�)..l.o!.t�:-:�.t."l t!-..,,.:;__,..:_�, ;-.._.,-.._�.-,r�t�..-._:.:.��.-�-�t�-1-l/~T t't�I�I.rr-��-u)_C_ ��-C=�-:....r�"-l .,. ---� C._:r�:�J:.>lt�:�:�'c�--' t-:~=---I~:V.. 1���=-�� r�"-�>� l. !"i�~.�.�-' '-.---.'.��-�;t"lC._.r�:':�:t.". l�l-�)-.C. .rV;l'(.t''�-~� t~.--�-'�) Even if the ~:eller of the good~; ::tre gen.;;-ral 116
DECISIOh C.T.A. C~~ NO. 4n1 - Page 15 - ;:t!lges p~-�.t.1�tJ�..:A�1~�r. r�- � . !"t.ow�� ..�),-.-;r~:.� t_..() 1���1),o;T~..�. Section l66(a.) allo~.v~; the sales h,::, (.�,+! �,�-:�:,...��ll�'-t�,�:��:,�.,�-}�'.=..'�,;-::,,.'.:;�:.:.l�t1�c-.-�4'-�� t.~-�t.l:�-:.:�. .._:�,-d;_1.:�:�:-�..�:--' t.���J;.v~~ ,.�.�.���r�1 t-l��,1:-:,, t"-t't�11'c�--'f�.1::�.:...,.�--l !n�'r�-���-,�,..��il�l-�r��.��.r�-�� �11��.c-�' ln., n0a �-�� �.� �.:- r-�,�;11�.-�1 ' t��JJ1'lt=>f"-t�r�l::1t111fClr�ttlf;:::.t� t1�1,::, :;1!"1(1 ��;-1��.-:�� .. �~� �c-���:-;�!,l.:-:,~:,.c�-:� t~~~:1.',4.!.. ~'"(',~ .';-'��-� f-;:=<c:c:,::,.,-�1 00 �tt--11.;:::. 0t�," "~ l l 00 ~ � ' - � 00 �--~ ~- .~ \...... 0 0 � - ' � � - � � - � "o' 00 o , '-� A �-�� O .. '�' '�' -... ,,..-..:- . ��i ��l.:.rl r�r��v\�1� �:)!" 1:, 11-.. ) '�-�� 1 !._ �-� �- t-l� �ld.- t-� t-l� �1�~' �.�:�:�-r1d.�~��-.-:'- t~.~:~..�...':�.. ;t�:l.._l �c..J��..�:.t.)�i.".I'.J�.���-:t t-.��:�-:� :.l'rr l�r�1'-�.1+1''...-....o-...t-,�:�:.--'�.�..1 t't�1 tA�.tl--...:~. 1 t1� t 1('. 1 rl tY. TVt-ll'I\1 ... 1�0�-::�::. r'}�,:-:-�!"1�r�-���t'�C�-:�l.f"l-r.���'�1tT t�� -.,, �C.�<�:.�!�.l.�:�..�c�--� .d.~.'�'���-:l��C-��C��O--::-:-:�.C�-�'C-;.:�:>t"I�!-..:�.r�1.- !",��.,�;r� -� H!-)) 7 �c--�t-t�'1i c..+..�..:.:.><t1~1�-� . I 11�,:-,t�l.:. Tr-~) t�..:_..-'.-..�:�-:\-1.�Jr�t�.t.ul.�=:..<;, t�;''.:,/.' .' r,�-tt.tl�r�r�I.:::.r J._.�fi::.:' '..I'. �.,J" �.�' 1��.-:~� t '..; t1, t....... (J.� ...1 ._. �lJl~.. ���� ..�V Jr..;� �t:,~... ~T ,..,tl11 ~'"/' Deficiency Income Tax for 19�~' 7 in tlle amount of P 1.474,4.37.60, incltt:;ive of su.rch~.rge, per Our comput3.tion, to \�'lit: 1987 - Deficiency Income Tax Net Income 1:::.er 'Return . p ~:.4,t.72.0.32.00 i�,.Jd: Ta.ze:; & Dut.ie::; - -~. ') 10 !:')64.00 ca.pit::1.l E~:penditu.re�; P.�;� n ~ ? q �) c::. ()f~ (�r N-2-t T::u�::abl-2 Inc�:nne ,)t....JJ . .f()w, I ;.��) .... ..,. T.., �� .:_l_.a:�~ [1. 1-1--~ T11P�-�.t�.:�-.�-'�-.}11 .\.-..�)';�_c):<- i�:::c'�J1 p 1.3,4.?:.3. 909.00 Ta.x P;::1.id 1�-:. 11 tJ,w')(�..). c}: ,w�-:. .�n.....�1��.) Deficiency Inc.::�n1e T:nr 1 ')�) rr-:. ~=- f.�(.1>:!~r:..) . (..1.�(._1._ Add: 20$ Sun::harge- ,u""' , !..)_ Tot;:;.l PE?r Court's Cornpu.t:;.tion * 24!:"; 7�;;(i_f.(! p 1,474,4'~17.60 WHEREFORE, ri��� t�� tAt,L.::-:, ._ t::''-�.���1�.C���t.��.�) ~ f.��)1� r_�;.:__..:,r.-rr-"v����;t}(l.t.=. �>-�!"1t.� (�-��,.�-��.,rI-l-�r.�1rt.�C-��O�-:'�t�,�.�.�.���r�L;.:,[ (��~,1� Interm:i.l Revenue da.ted I��I.:)vembe.r 26, 1991 is hereby modified. 117 ��--��- __ _J
DECISI01.- C.TA. CASE NO. 4721 - Page 16 - ACCORDINr.LJ tr-- u ����t�,�i.:::.t��-���1 1�c� 1�1�1 l .' !r-��.".�.:�::..�Jt.1t-1� �,�-:�-� ,t�l~~�t� __, l"�Pt-.::.1-..~T t._.. �- ��-� 1. '=:="f.__ ._..) p-��:�1-~-:;r .J. �-� ��-� ....- ! ��r� 1 .;:;. ���:=. nl~f....' r.�~ 7 7 �=.� �1. Li .;:;. .' J. 1 J..� J. ._.1 t .I.� � .I ;:i. �.~.� ...-1~1�1�..�.�1�Pt"l.r.�~T 1.�.-.�,!- 1�~�-��-c��r���H�.�)�t�1�!�..1�t�:-�i1�1,t_. t.l�J�.1�'=��::' :-:1� r�r�-,-,-..:,1-1�!"-' t.. �'-�--:.t� r> -�. �� �v �/ L ..-,!�r�,,::, t,:;nt tt�r.:::. nine� it�l..-. !������t� 1�t�l���tnc�t�vc. ���,1� .-.. �.� �.� J. �.� ...._,.,~,..., ��..� u.:::.:=lf. 10P'7 �.L �.� / ��� �-- (�.!.-��(!'�~ �c-q'r'�-,�.-..1.,�. -,J~.lt--'.r:.ir=t,:��:...� ,I :.� �,_) I _1 l.. ��.� -��-' � '�,� f._. .r-� �) --~ i..1 2CJ$ intB-rB-st 1.=:-er annum irom the da.te prescribE>(! for payrnent until iully paid pursu::u1t to Se-:::tion 2.:;3(a.) of the Ta.x Code. The U)tnpnnnise p;;-na.l~.y impc�:::ed l)y respc�ndent in her deficiency l�r--Hr~-��'��.�Jc--�.�::�:�.'���1 �'>:'.c~�� �j'l--� r�.�.'�l��.�.....:.:_-...:_:�, "d'���..�Jt-.�. .�:�~.n1.r.-..,.'�:...'-,:.\!- t.l1-�:f�.t.. nr-����~t-1�.t1�-��'��-��)!.11:�::�:�' r� ��:1�.o;::.t�."-=."."-=."',-j tJ��.�J t't--r=�� 1�!-!"irr-�"���./�.._.:,-.~i. t-l���'�'.1� "1 . T\�I1.,:.:-. !"1�-1��1�t":�" 1.-,-:.' .'�-.�.'.�-��,�t�I�lrrl-��',��1-"..'!"11. c�-�'��~ rr---'t�:�"�t"l.�:-l.�lt1-�.T/ '..�-...,:-~...1-i!"!!�.�j�t-� t�..::- l�t-r�.irr��''(�-)C�-'P....�'"...l (�-1� 1" J ��� (.�..,�...-.�,ll.::�:�-:�.,.�,�t..:�:�:..�...-.1 1,;,,,1�t.t.-!L..-.,,'�,'� t.� t.l��ic�._.. �-.~~..�-:.rt�..:�:�-".=-. t'�"f"l-P.. t..�,t~ ��:::>'.r�! r..l t.....,....�,t-l fn�-�r�t-H - i.t,1,7 t�.����f t.l�.r�...:.:.- t'-�:'-~��q'":,'--�:�.'1�'1lt:�~.t� . u ' (Wonder Mechanical Engineering Corporation v. Co1lt of TaxAppeals.. L-22805 & 27858. June 30.. 1975. 64 SCRA 555J The Defi(:i.ency Sa1t:-s Tax Assessment for 19t~7 in the a!rK�unt. of P 192.312 0.}. cancelled ;::md set aside. i��-J��,�.�!��c-��t~c_.� ��:Jtn:-P�::>�1�1�r.c_..t. nr-����~tt.�"r._t.��...-.,n- ..::.:..r�. SO ORDERED. WE CONCUR: ~...l:)~~ ERtlESTO D. ACOSTA 118 ' . . -~--~� - ..... - -
DEOSIOl - C.T.A. CASE NO. 4121 - Page 17 - CERTIFICATION 'T1 lu.s 1.s t.o (:ert..H.y t...lia.t, t.~..le a~~:n:)�ve (leoS. H. )n "-<'-;a:; reaCi~lE'(l af"t.er ' 119 ,....... .I
More in CTA Decisions
- UNILIVER PHILIPPINES, INC. v. THE TREASURER OF THE CITY OF MANILA(CTA Case No. AC-41)
- COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE v. MAERSK GLOBAL SERVICES CENTRES (PHILIPPINES) LTD.(CTA Case No. EB 2534)
- THE SECRETARY OF FINANCE v. CENTURY PEAK PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT, INC. AND KINGSVILLE INTERNATIONAL RESOURCES, INC.(CTA Case No. EB 1776)
- CTA Case No. 1513 (Decision)(CTA Case No. 1513)
- AVON PRODUCTS MANUFACTURING INC. v. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE(CTA Case No. 7873)
- CTA Case No. 5654 (Decision)(CTA Case No. 5654)
- DNATA, INC. v. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE(CTA Case No. EB 842)
- SAN ROQUE POWER CORPORATION v. COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE(CTA Case No. EB 248)
Want an analysis of this document?
Ask ASG Legal AI to summarize it, compare it with other rulings, or explain how it applies to your situation — it researches from this same library.