CTA Case No. 571 (Decision)

P IILIPPIN AP EALS � 7 ����� -� � � � ). ' .., �. 437

. c. 7 ,. 2 .... f . J.l . .. ................ J.' c . pp l l 1; .i r c . PP :IJ'g l!'l ~� � t.~.� th ..r y tn ..'.. },.,., ,., and a t�x du t fo:r u du 1..0) 0 �'t 1C o.f :tnt s ;Jli r.r (' r � p � ......11) ... trt& c ,. rt~ Xf~� OJ: 1{ ..;,.} !t :J v l7t SftJ. U . fC;c t ~ . tth !.1-:''."11 . �\"'lJ:. �~ J "J' ... I .f ' 438

.. . 71 . �7 .� J. ) "" i c .. J tt ... l"- �_: . J,.j �. ' �1 .... �!�"~;J.. . (..... * � �� .. 439

~~""� ~I ! ." � �����-� ...�...�...�.�. ~ . r� ' .t ~~... � ... " ............ '� ...... ... ..... �� l� � ' l'll.'..._ ...""...r. . l.,� . .. ".! ,.,., .,} \J ~1'('\;.: � U'l July I 440 I

c. � � " 'D.�(';'!:;) T ,~' <ilf .. .... 1- � '-.tl~ �.-.:. .~..v. 'll � - t. J: fund of th U!U t .. t yi f .. ,. '...:.:. - t1ot cn ~ 0 t~ !. (} 1 1 fUao. etyonQ. ct l of fl yond t lt !n t nt fw: r Vf.ew � a~v�" �uly fil' it ~ a .e .-V ~ thfit t r ..e ,p 1tione:c filed t elat~ vr 0 :tnvolving 1 ftn: ntc, . cla ~ or .. �t 1at tJ t r po1d nt ""Oi!ten f .n . re on& and th eta.~ . �me t~1.a .. t. d: '. tt c of :v . ' i l � l~57 11�. us,;:.. ~, � t 11 tt ~. �tn h n ~ . -t .:. ' ht ft aaca ot ' r :iJ � ,!O.:JJrl;. th � V~'~'"S .... t :est &.. t tl4 .1

- .~ t; t �cr, \:1 ,.. 1,) r ~ ~- .. . t �� \ � r n ~ 1 c 0 .., v f 11:~7 .�... 1 f ..v 442

� � .:ot t. c � � y ct t t t � _� 0� ly c .r . ly ... .'" .!L /. c �~ f 0 ... �t .1 0� 41 4 4' 3 c 19 .,.. . � c f�. it !. ~~4

- .. 571 !� t 1 n actf 1'2 � (' "t -}l . t ~:;r . it'l . c!n_ for r. rt; fi no " c ... t n� il ~.ri 3 n: DO d �f ~ 0 ct 0 - th (; p rat� and d!ff X' t PJ r- .' 1 r.,t ...ute o::: t ��~ i�Jn d ... � � ' I J luti!'�Odwt

i ( 71 .. 9- tn t ly up u t � 1 ). �� � � .. � x \j rl ti 1 � t n � f 1 'l i l 0 � 1 fr � X� as i9 t It t � 13, � t 0 ct t 445 .....

671 -l " t� st n. t t � X 0 tl � 1.1 .. � ��� ���������������������� 3, ������������������ T ����������������������������� t � � � � -� D � � � o. �� 1 ' . �� � l1 � � � � 1 at u ' 1 ..... �t ly 1 y � y � 4'46 l' ft C'f �* '+' .d .511111��.,.�-r..._...,*""���----~-.~~ -�-

� �� � � it ) - � t � � � ' ( � 1 � 1')� f � y p- ) ; .tl p j � 1 Y� ;n � 447

, tf ci 1'tll{;Ut � l 1 ... ( "'"' n t X r3 lin } ~nc .. e rro ,., l t 1n '� '/i~; ,. � � .-,~ J f ,; .d .. � ~� n r ~~~ r&~et� :~v {c J (1 ) {D) (as imple- \\ 448 I

l i � f..1 i I l 13 � l I t . .. � . 4t.:1. llfJJ:'i l ....,.., 19' .th r-e th r s ond t -cl + .c I .; i 1. ta~ int r . cl 'n. t.. d Ct:r.g; � tbi;;; Co� rul t lijt ~ ts a r � ?., ") 1} v.f VU:t. rax Coo�,, . p tnt.. � ne 449

... � ~7l .. h t est on i d: t ruu t.m �c not t � X G ~.tncier ec .1 n '"' {ci{l (J' ocl---�� w "t � on �' � (bJ(l} Ot r V!d �: 0.~.,. ll'l t a) t t.. (bj hai t i\,,il � ua ( ~ .... , ;~aio � �e .. l l i$0. of (.. � ') !1~5) � f'' .n.ft- h �s:ttc t 450

til """"'. ~ ... . . ,� . ''I � ~� "t~ ? ... . 'l ' " " ...� .l .... 2.~ � ~up:r.~ � � � .:; ! �.d Jte. r - t d � � � f ro:.cur.c t.l..rn l'l.... f1 1 :�thO<J't � 1":;1 ... . � p abstained . 451