CTA Case No. 5052 (Resolution)

t.' n ') t:o 1 l id 11 ~ l 0 h f ui s fQ ll l ] I ~ 'flC\1? p 1. fl t.h t. w t th ,... ~t 1 . n l p 48

l 1t - � Ay M � ch 'I !1.Q!. lC' t 1 n "' fle 1 ' r fo1... ttl h th 1 fo�~ 1 1 nr 1 r l ~r d [I 'I 7 - lTA .. led to T ."l the G F l. - 'II; t 0 antl t l ondt w \"' nne1 tht� 11 1 n h ., ll p vnt d nd . ' 49

s .~ o. 052: paid to R pond nt h e �o\.mt f P 4 Lf , l TI ett le f!' t of t h 19Bl d fic1 ncy docu� nt )~y 6 mp 6 mn ; P3l,e a.1o lTI n 0 h 19 1 d ficiency lTlCO H nt Tt 1 lJ ged l b of th 1f 1981 t1H d d Wl hh ld n . �. &.5 en nh lit y 1& Id R $p n h 0 d .... ll ettle n f c: d lC n y nco p rc nt 9 c)( nd xp nded wit old n n' . nd rei>p ct y l nn )( ) Notw nd h f e ld ll d C'O pro� 1 f# py n& oc pl.,O h Cl~l 1 n c s �. Ti .p J nd am on A. Alb Nos. t COl nd 9 se o. 91 7 h CJ"'i llll 1 a l1 d wr dl fill s fi n h dy ' micably d h )"' b o t��e a,.. nc.:l I i, h, n 0 now, 16 ttll ,d n 1 ton lt l p hi J( f ~ ,.. 0 r hl th ud on 0 lJl a W< 1l ec: lY d by fespond nt compr'OIIIl s 1de by. s tt l ... nt bet wh1ch sh ftl d to hQnot.. Tid ...... 50

RESOL JTI C.T.. c No .. It Th Re pond nt, how v )ft d n1 d th t co111promise ...ttl lll�>n nd th p t1tlon r .alleg1ng ' n fi l~ he 11 eged tu11 w s r en d b tw . t th ong 0 h �~s, hc;t pay� nt de on Apr� l 13 ' 9 :::> th cr1JD:ln l ct on& agiuns v. Hor C'lO Pobl do� nd fl IliOn A. Alb 'r"t & off'i er 0 tl lOTI ) 0 1l1tuJ nd n w l 1 Ul~E' to p y h l l 2 d flC n y mn lt dy p nd n n co ...n"'t t of or n uppl1 d� CTA e OJd ,:.;. 41). ...Dus h then , lfiOV t th 9l.,OUO that .. h . 1 no h I nd1ng b en re1n pet it on nd pond m C' as c.~ . ml :n 1 5�> 14 of f the NlRC 0 1f f '1 l of ' Maka B n h 14 ' litl g . 1on Jn d tl 10n �houl b d l d 0 ' l n 1 e l l 1 of t .New Rul c Ul " P� We ., olve th 1101: 0 n y I of h f po n P tlt'lon 1 1 p t l 1 n fo lly d�l ted, ' C' cl d II s n, S!io\.1 d h dn' ef<H"' s 10 cr1 ., ) 15 u nd (He to r solv d ln t fOl"'l' d cl~l llll n ca s, p ll 6\.1 nt 0 th �.. 51

RESOLU I C. T.. ~ � Ca e No .. 5 .. Revent Cod <P tition for Rev1ew. . p. .. ) nd hast n d to dd, how ve th t "th i n~H t nc: of r r.ponden COIIIIIU 5 i OJHJl~ l T olding on t the C:O p OIU payf!J n , whi 1 e h �" Pt~osecut 1 on Divi s1on refuses to hono~ r.uch co p)~omls., s wholly i 11 gal .., nd bl ... l � (Jbld. W und nd th ~ d1c � n of th P 1 on r yet We c nno lh , wh ch i s ln ~ r1c bly n. rtw1n d w h th pre nt foJ refund, h )l~ dy b c "' 10 1 nd IOC:On S b}e and th ~~ for no lon r w1tt11n Out~ h gu Court cqu1 � d th J 1 d1ct 1 on ahe d of U nd r.hotld 'e ln th f1na res ol\.lti n. Jn f ct, P on l n v l bef ore th s Co 1 t f l y b 1 lfl th t 1 h r g\.11 r Ot.ll"t W 1 h 1d q�u r d IC'h Jll dJC -on. And right 1y o. H nee c nno ,~.... J on h ce l ~l te 1 lly d p nd nt on h s Ill c se. Si Npl y put W c nnot s um J n~1 sd 1ct 1 on ov � the l' fund case r.1nc W w "e not ble to ssu th a � n c se. On .. nno th r fo� , be separat d h othe Wl ho�. VitO) lOg h doc � .10 of "11u lt1pl :t y 0 Ul t" ". Th ' l' 1 s l y, w th pronounc m n of the Supreme of tho Co m:t~Dione~ of lot rn l ~ venu 52

Rerot.:U C.. l . . . o. of App � 1 , Ci y ~u nkJn Corpo tion -nd Cow~ o x App 1&~ G.R. JO 611 July 21 1994 wh ch rl..tl d, hu : 01 \1 LV, th 0 VOld uJttp) 1ty of Re pond n 1s h r by 53

RES ur C. T. A. Ca e No.. 5Q52 7 suits pur su~nt to S~ction 1 (e) Rule lG of the R le& o CtH.trt. I 54