CTA Case No. 245 (Decision)

REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES COUl T OF TAX APPEALS MANlLA t 0~ I \ c� ~ t;. � � � � J.;J � � Je: -. -- t. - - ---. - - - - ! .... l 0 ~.., o..f.! � t .1 .. uc r. - , s :..l of p:r p i , 'r 4� ' hi"\ s .$ 12. ( f t 3 ,4~ 0 fiG X , 1, 19 l~"'a, ,1 -� t. d 1... 4i fo t d i f � t. t 0,:: r a... -... p tt c l il Cvi 1' i c ... ni t ... s y ,. 'l 56, 1 l0 177

>10. ,... 5 -2 ... y b. cou 1 or t spont.ent. $ d yt pr 1: u t o, 48, oll c f l "u tion as c.m i () ,1 �1 5 fo l . ,-. ~ 41, ,....:! . fte tit.i l -6. ' q t i $ d l.SP �t :., i re ..s $51� t n ht h 0 th n o_th � ~ to t sponde t , u ... hQ p f whot ha uly tl "" . ... l. t,;() 0 r 1* il" � tl. t oun 19., 1 7 . 7 � 9 6, a r ld ion $ ofi'~ an . on ns p � ..,. ~ l y '� s p "j F .oru ry J , 1~56 .. nd t puo c i;,h >ro}:J .rt ~ .iz d ci i -.rOll.> r rd� y , -~ y 26, l I....o,. . p ~tit:\.() ter ..: '1 11 , 1 56, it~ p i io 0"' R�V't! h Prel .m.... 0 l. i� is s n i ly fo tl+ 4 "" .......<J ~~ ..i i li . -1 � rnas. "C t& tho. c ~ �� t r0 n 0i s i l �� " ? 17 8

� -. in t ~ f 1 h 't t ri y to lv pro 1 t t1 t t" t 1 �� of sev 1j y rs n fiv ( } nt.hs ae QC> on ... t t : $ io<;o tax s d 9 in t et 1� rul j � ri jQri6p~ud c al tc t y s yt nt l {3} t e r :rn is al ri ci 1 ~n in ....>ecti.o 51 ) of t a o a long n o � g s, n l Vita v 40vrrun � h~ . ipp I'Ql nds , - hi � 2 2; oll cto cf Su � �) t l l .J. � !:''.). ~ .. '-'4 . , c. s . Po nt � r , c. ... n a �o' � � � ~> � r~},. "'< , nn � ..,. ... t . � .ch , c r l.:lt' i .. ,. No . L- 8 9. t ; P� ~ 'J�' � � \,. l c or.. �� � � .:a � . -.. � \.; ctor. .,. � f.J �; .. � c l t o � � � Cas � 11... 179

� c. ). ha 6 t ar. t :reeord do wt tur an i V"TY 1� al to tbe r , t a . s- t r t a 'r t 1� * c u t tn �Y .r st 1�,; it tio f:ror s id ~. e. undo t dly , t ut~o� G �1 ( 7) y. l' f.i {b � Ol th ,.t r a . d .� cc ly, th d l�vy \�a in �o... 1t t .h- ' eve. :. Co� .� 'tb >C t�on 51 u) of ha e enue ), t . � 4 :.. ' nt o:r th er . o col 't l. ....... � . ~ ht 1 Of! t:etion ... 2 ( ) provi e CIG L.o1�e s 0 f ary l r ''e ue t X h b hir. th pa i l i"t te til -cu :rs � h X ll�. ay co ec �au y s r 1 t "�Y 180

t y r. e l 1 � . f r :),.. 7- ~55 .) l .) ct on f t � 0 ) prov~ s

... 2 ..c:.:.,. -... 6 h � pi t 'I 0 oll v . 0 � t u. t� � nf -c ) � 1v d.l �� 6, 11 ,;,;.l" iS ha . "" t i ;;;# -f ' X0 r1 n ro 1 tak. a 'I fur r .... h .. r oi... lio ~ ie~ 5 e l at.. - �on is t 0 :26 , 1~ J l i.ti ' �j ....., , ~;;. 18 2 -