CTA Case No. 1346 (Decision)

11�. t' U I'H ;\C 01 TOE PHlLll"PJN r.l' COURT (J)F TAX AftPE.AL8 QUEZQN CITY �1 L 8 10 0 r r 131

P�.C:t.:I Oii .... c� . c o. 13 6 2 � . , 955 ( �P "" 1, P� lt. . _r,.� ith n u I ll<). a t nt of 1ts r1 n-e1 l or 1 55 1 ' d 2,?; ., ( Xh. � 9f r .). ncom- t X of id p � 53. 2 f '\ \.1 1 nd - ~ 1 1 t 1 )6 1on b j ' � ry 1 19S t r inv _t1 t .1ng t r turn or t~ ;. cl pt . r .o, 1955, & n .ss :s tr or :p ' .. 75E, re urt 0 1ts a.ceu 1 t d urplu� 1nt to lov .r bl ... . ~� n .... � 2,7~ ") t u � � �� . . . . . .. ..�.. � � . . . .-======- �~~~~~,..... � .. . � � ~ tv 1 . fio1 ney t x rch 21, 191 � D o ii-3 � r. 1,. .n e , p . 16, CT c. ) . l ~ r11 21, 1961 1 p t tioner. t o gh its ud tor, t il� ith r &pond nt 1 n t 1 prot s i th l l � Y nd V l1di 1 0 t � .X te en 1 ad c 11 ion ne of n t h f ( 1) 132

133 ..

� 1� ,1 '. � c- c ? 0 ' t c .a 7(1) 0 1

, c urt o T 1 iv 1 w. b . aston r o lnt& rl&l Rnv�~rn11 ot ... ti r r � in ne U:e C ()f othe:r la at1 �1 14 . r ~ta isi ,s' 1, t ~ n or on th g in t nd t the� ss .asment ... lf' fs ., s... 3~m r Q ln rn . ~ $1. ' � 2 9~ J nu ' " 1 �� .P' � oll cto or nt 1 1vt.t ?nil �. 31 ) � ';'~bEn et! o r Q\.HJ ion~ l i ity o r ~onden �s a 1' 1. 1 ncr r u 1 to r.c ... n1 't ,. Js ut .d t. n l r h t th or , thf! rig t to ppe$1 to t .$ Co r t1pon .� �C sm nt, s1 po l nt Ot'l d! sp c on 1 t) of � . 125� . _) y t I , or 1 o l� 13 5 �

.. 6 po t d n� 1 of ll?'S81� 1 co tnx t 1t �l th n tt - I ct� rt n d pjt~ h t1 ion� , t 1 t ntam~trur.ft � t ele r 1nc1ic ion o b � t " . g in t t e d ,t"1<d nc J.ne 1 t h 0 he (2/ y a t o ot it Pl' t 611. 1-se t that, tt tax- h� t� C: le $ t 1d T t0 s t ..... t1 � r ... al .... e ue t t . l' 13 6

� ... �1 7 1 oe 1 t 1 11, �1 - 0 t 1o.n ( ) t' � 0 0 t 137

o. 1 y 1, 1 1 ( ., � t n1 alr 3 1 or t 1 c .r v ... y 11n 1 () of � - 1 3 8 ,I,� '

13f+6. b � s. w t t p tl . ' th .t p t1- l' :n � b oa � f 1 h ViO t1 t Seet1on 25' 0 0 ' crt t b o 1 heo o � ! i c r in 1 'U ' 1 t t1 q tion ot �r ct and th c:1 rc eonst1tut1ng it u . ......,..~..,. ( C 1s. 1 r t Int ern ' t l., b o se it ~. )� r ( u' 1. H .rd- eri ~ char re Co. v. Coul" ot Tax p$.- ela, et 1. , G. 'R . N � 1 2"J , J nua r 28 � 1961 ) 4 ! t 'P t be ..tiiA:~~ 1 ati f t oril i f n t eon- on it od v . .Phil. 104 De ) to~ v � .o n of th 3 � <1 inoo -C t l"o, 18 1. 84; lli> ' � e. 116c , 1 4. . J: 139��

� D CISIOI- � "TA� S: .,. .NO. 1 0 wi 1 r-� r tX 'll � -l' b l' eno s 0 1t r ra �t ( . ."r u h �1 ) 1' t orr. e: 1 d 10 th t nlus, would l. u 1 '1 0. fr al- ! on h r 0 ' v ben n od ,.)( i re of' ".'� the ... ,. ' th t ~Q ,,/o 25' or th � Co t1 n bli ot l)l' ~ 'Tt �Orl h bPe u .~ I. .r r h 1'". 1 r . 22 ) � 1 Unto.~ 'r t conVin r 1 t spnnd � l'! t ~b. o t Co rt a y c I. i orr~ . 'l 1:c. � !}, - 1 t ion of d nyfn �oner's J1J"C't st c~ h . (}) dld fraud 1 t,. 1 n r*s 1n... co X r tu d cl rati n. b ond elo u n r u th l1C r u ~d t " 'll ul . ten to !; 14 0

. 14t

.' .. , t l ~M t Jl ly 1 � t 11 �t tion tor inem !ftent il t'i v ( ,5) Q f'il i lit r n o Jo.. 331' or the i flU lie of t ~ R1 a : . m � o J u, u. � o. \74.3 , 13, � 196lt. ) { 1 or~ p$ �1t1o et .t1l .d i e 1n<Jo ~ to 1{),,.re u for t e fi l y 3 0 ,. 1 b.t 0 29 , 19~0 .. .r.. 1� � u -� by r pon~ on t b 1~' live (!j) y t t1l1) ... ri ot lb .) n 0 tlo . ~ )l"'4t 1 at a o � ' s �� t ;, 14 2

� 13 " c 10 nt of t � he In n f 75 ' 7. is rs d. Aecordi t n tteot. �ithou t o , o.r 0� .. I0 /L__. J ~' lA!� Of L. Vrt !iC� ~ A o at J d r.'i nJd Umal1 id ot t part . ,, 1 4 3