CTA Case No. 1580 (Decision)

,,t~f'Ufll,IC OJ' TBF. PHILIPPl:NEI � COURT OF TAX APPE.AL8 . QUEZON CITY 0 .�G 0� . p � c .-:.~ 4 o,. l;: . . I �_, :r \". 306

�2 f1 of t.hr- ir t.i 4(~ !l .; c c t' '� 1 l. t 1961 � ic a ll. �.e.CllJ ~l,t" .d all th ilc :..t: i �::J t n 1t1on... s� 1~~ 't~ io r. � tl � lat ; . ". co i;} .l 19 � title. .:tr ..y '..lso ib t f ---."' ~----~ ~--~~ ' �tr ' 1 t cr ~... ' 1 i .19 {t � .'J � � � ;.), . . r..pr 11 r,., l .r _ , r11 ;: - t h-�h Jo t et1 r r ~o 1 J. ~p rt ' nt ...,. y~o~~,__;, '...f...... . .. ~"' ... 1. t t l � .; a I'?. t ' y. �) ~ l ~ct tv1 1 s . "-' . ct 11 itlur.. ( t�' - .,; rti c of 0 p A ut D � lnV a~ 111 . f old r !11 "'.. t or s .�. i d :. f-

3 l1ed ro.r t1l w , :.�,....:. .!'! '-u ' t � ,. .' 4t . :� loor, 6?6 t.a . ;>;1 , oa 1.1La .for a ll .;~o vi oV.;. t .01 o ;e .� �~36 1. t t .... 0 l . "" 0 \1.1 .r lller;:-tl po:>t!l!? "' �3: � �,. ive p~p r . ' l-l a, 7 6 , ~ ' )). v "� 4:'G:IC. � ''l.!ltl .(lJ i l ',i '! � t'1 ' ""tl- c ". i�..'ll ta ro ' -,o:.+r... -' ;��. .'.r... r .of 'lti!: �:-a , ng ocu r.~~ m ~ ~ � ~rl 1 S\i: t r;;;, ch~ e :.:> , ne<,.ot1 $ tel ;.>1 lla1� reco j,,S �e . ... i za, tot.' b. e t G 't' t.:n ... . '~. , 1r. "'1 in l a r 1 or J.oo .. f otc ook~ c � n- tr n 1 te ( ':.; r. s � :: , c- ... 1, .. h r".''~". i . , -1 to ... r c. ) .s r c 1tt1 te t1lo ,f; 308

~ . 1580 t pr .. ..r nl . ..... 1 { � � . V� , '* ' '0 J..u l t ltJ!J:; ! il ~~ w1tu C1 I '1h t �nl a on or i t j.J i t� ""' � 1 ,;: J.' v ,.)j (; 1a .c'.S: l !l 1.0o1 r:! O! ". j 1.1. _;vtJ".. � 3ti "...' . . d. �t'o:r tt r t _r a r. cp n nf l �f'of' ~ t....;�~ <It t 'l -~ l n 1 ... oha r c t o.... vlu�uc 10 r;a f.'t1c1 n of p t t tiot: ~� � t.. r ". t H' .. . . . . I .d � t J;' . ""~' t': ~ c .;. 0 v! : 11 e r_ .,w.\" ~ ;,.. i~~ ... ten * t ' t t (. Ci ,. t 1.on ' 1o t h� " f Oi~ t l ; ~~ ~ i i l $ 0 � 11, r f or per 1 e 309

.' 5 ' � tr i t 1 10 t .. � (, 1 0 5'"' r t i ' t ~ '1 1 .) � ol , C' 0 l n. .. ) ol r 1 1 lO , c 310

�l Ci l �t � I' . ' 0 11 1 �� t 31

... " .t� l:~J~ 7 d. '� 0 t �r -. t l).fl , 1 1 - l nd, j � ~tt~ . or 2 _,~- Q !f.1~ t:rf 1t rt � t 't e �n (. �- r..ot ~ pet 6l . . . . .. i1 l !'!)Ol"t(! � flO d. o.t* ~21..�� t:� ., OV' r1 'th. � ' tro � l" :t'll t:' t:.. 19 i: to NOVE?llfi � ~ 2 c p r '1<l 'G 11' l 9t>2 oint n Q t 312

t �ic t�� � � ieh �o - C..1 c 1:. or 1c1 "' L� .".I.' r- � l .l ;.::.!. ) .1. ��� � �)"l .1~ or: � H {~rt~. t tt.i ... 1por ' ... �1:'1! roll J.thi!l..- ..... a� , l. �l \.. ~ "'GC . ; i .v. '� u. .1OI' t,... .. � ..- .J. . 11.;~. o. . 11k -. . � tp f r . .. t 13

of .. � DO f� H�r fr; 't-., 1ft .J n 1 t lr t l! �~;,. . 1..., d n tao '1*!" ... �r;: t1Y f.l'lOUl \ t1 t e tl \ n'"d 0 p.: O'lOl Ot' \ 1-. t .. i �' p.rt j~ ! .... Cl.Jl' � in.. t. ~vc �,. t. !) t th ir r t;> �r'Q r� at1'~ :.4 t :t; l;r . d a....d II\ " te �� t !t tb :r n 0 pt' 't.l~ l " t�o 1~� 1c.f..l......�.,. .. .. �b � wl ~, .�.u t ...~ ot -0 314

" l' ..... ' ., I c 9$ , �ttion h p r~ dt 1 t tl& the �ei �c n 0 '.i l'l? t . t f rB 1 t on.s :l cl ~"'� f,~S r.en � rer b f.L.Q n :l""e'::t... p 1 J. on t ' n. .l a o c uti ot t .b. ;_{ ~ t t.-1 {i t�~ t� ' ' ! 'I t ,. J * t.1 ( .... . ... . o n.). h . er , .t ur . e ...� .".'-. ll 'I) , ... ,.. o" '\ <:J- '' 31P .

ta e nd ft . "r'o 1 .. et o tb ~ t te- t1 ou "9 1 c on 1, co t 0 st .nt 0 obv a tl tu tl.on ( t . s � . � pp. lo?-16 , su sti- l 1-l~ J � o! ll 1! ; .. 1;1 S:<:>i o r~ ... aient ' ... cb.ar~o ers �..I no" Pelo f;. .Q t .{!; et- � ~~:.s .:now 1<ti�� ...t1;;,; �-� ~-e C O� S no~� bow t ..::>. Ohr t' atE;t h.OW to .J:"f:Jlt (lQ fi,li::.h as on� she n l 1 0 f oc� .\; � (~ 0 rue ~hli.! CI' ot' tnts Court to CQ s1u r ,,. cr o�ttt1o~ .n n tte n on l bor n � ' n� .. 19 1 r ... r 18 r .. ,,:�< ' o~ . ot now t.o 318

d '1 . �. 1 t . ,�tilnon.r .) t { � ..h {0 � 3 'tn t 0 { 0 '1 t J 3 t �- ff;!St .. () n .f'f't \~t:.arn o.f $ _, .rett \arr ran . nd � ~ . J �rti~1 - ' "? � ' 7t !"oldor B �' 1" "';fJt;_; 1 r �I t mt 1c in '"'1 P 'e io tr 1 t. r,_ r >J>l�"' t.., - 1, ,o . * ?!)- ,; ~ ' ; ~� ~ .e.; " ) t. t t. !'lll""f , n .. t !1 ' '..{ l o r . a .~�.�-.X . 0 \l r. pu "1 � f f' c ll .) .:.:�ro �. th~. ( "' or o:r t;b. 1~ r .n, a c1 J. a 1on ve � ot .o , , .....7 '.c; r' .r 0 317

..' ',.;, � l!J-'~~ 3 of ote s ' (') tt L oub. 1 lena p�:.. .,., � v t� .c; .r c ion 2, . \ .Ill "It", r 0. rnc . .... ,r n .... w i: :1. ... TP nt 0 . ). a 0 � CQ ... � ,F lo t" ~ 1n 1 r �pJ. - to n u ot e or � h . ()l nts i:J s l"l�l" y l 0 - ~> '!/ tr r 1 1 II l' tte i I' ~ 1<l1n, cl:le X' t. e : .... ! 1 1 ,;. on " ~.rt1o 1!'9 t' it r10't. .,..tie 0 .t \- 0 0 pcti a eo ,;r, - to U!" 1� 1 t:. n.v il .. ie . ,- i~ifld tct th . l'} � ZEW 1, 1 � n e or 11 . t'0 ' or t n 1o - p t'J 't. ~lotts, th. f n �C. 1 . nno c ~t . h c I" rry,. (f ~...t; l 0 th~ 318

IC .. l~ ~~. r"l.~~~ .t ,. t ~, ... . - ~ ~ , ~ �.'(. ;.'....., ~.(~ l ito r � U'n. �. .. he docu � nts . tt t � 2i c l's ' co d our , r .turn Q tbe 0 1 l1s (J abov .. 'L ., aid ot1o 11k is { �x: � =~ ; ~' � 14, "!T"' r c.). liro the "'o.rego1t\ rea 1 a . ot tact , ' c1.r ea.n nO".ti t d t..-.. . .. l"O er� l 1 ... ' In ao t. r i... . bl n t i"' 1t1 o:ns t. �. th~. 'oc ...,'I' J � n'"' or t r 1 a � �! t ' co pl c-.., . f pttl t n rs a r �or t .. 1 � y t ~ ol o i tt:..etr r otll 1 : . tt t ra net

15 l"et r �.1d if the> &! et at1o e� r ffl h .. Q. f � ion � 1. :.~vl. l , h ~ 0 rv oc lly ~long to p~ t1 lor, r � r l l t �3 0..r t r' 'i t �ntri ot1c w r l t �... e-s oul �Ol f.f cr cow t X on n . $ :11.~ t hrz. il $l\. 1al. Q() J~ t "' h t tt t.hii'Y n it SU~ !. et. . ... tha �, c e t 1 l d b ~ GOd by r suonr1 � n t.o Q"" t .;, o i { i.e " � <V<1 � � � tlttoner cln1 >J p ti u.onor c o r; ' n1 t y l- 320

\ !i.Cl~�I t ... " e (' �� ~ .; . ~- : 0 . 1 i'~ t -1 0 '�'i �, r l th oa~� te~~ ir diap .. l {~ 1 0 f,l 1 sr p r ln ~t � .d �. :rtun t~ ,. re \l t J_ C i" Okl :~ t 1ll v ~' t l;ln- ,>ot .. l � ... ':r: :;';.i..., !~ll:Zt t.c pOt "' � 1 ot n ' 1 \h~ a 1 ;~ti o. (.1, � 1 ��� .t.U'~flil l\1 t 1! l t.o ..r -~ ii ' n ~1 n. .~.~ � ut:. 'l.�t e t � 0 d ' aa.. '- !,l ..,~; t...s.i Co���.- b e;; ~!.i ~ p�l 1t1 �r� , ., r:� , . il f o t that "), �)b.O tos ta t eo !I d F,, tt .. 1 (..'. ,"."..... . 0 ... ) 1! to ... 1&1 , ls 32l

Diroi� 10r �r: r.~ � E A o . 1 ~ v 17 � !. � t' � .. l'"' ) f oqu~ nta c rt ai.n< d b t.d otec ' ~...or n �u t �~ 0 .... the 0 trover lal ) "' J. h . - :uro. .n o.f. � 322

,. t.:. (/tl't c uAS~ ~o., 58u 1 323

324

�1!..0 ISIOfli ... C..:: i:o~:~~~ ..,o . l53C s n:t . d t -i. � tian of p . � 1t1an ... � t o of !113!h5 1ng th- . por1qd !ro Jan~. 'f:'1 23 , 19{;2: tQ .Nov~mb r 24, 6 1 s d en .,. ~ 1bitrJ -;..... � o "" ?' , s t.ra . ~;1 d -l -h1 i t .;1 , t onJ; ( 1n p 1 ~ ..a O:J r tn o pat1 io~ r � tU t .lt �962, 1t 1 ionor , n (;. t th $t lv s 1 n the eo tr rvers1 doa nt .ra th t V! c t .1 ae :& � intt. t 1o.t.Grt.H$.t& :Of ) itiono.r ) p .. fe . ..., ls r 1 aa a n t in- 32S

P]!".Cl . O.N - C,r,~ CAt~E ~~o . l5-�0 21 'b p y t � e tr er1pt. e fir , petl 1 n. JJS 1 ... e. o n 1 .,oo .�uo 1n io ... t1l~ Ct.Hlrt 1'0181 1: ~�ttl um:uuatrt:i . l td t les ltl. ed 0 , :h 'h tlhGJ l t eeU ct fti� f .. � .. n � P� 3:.} �. th.at ,etttion rs w G hoJ.o slsr& ll . . ., c t ,.,. i l � ~~ 1 i. .~..n s~ $trat gi~ ll.Y !l t n ttftr t �t t r -oT .r )f b~;t .ina.,., 1 bris.tt; nn - 'W t ... t ~jSJ cap1t 11~ 1o of o�: .r oe � cat l !'014 ~5~ .... . ". ~"' r 96~ o t e G nd tt . . !" --:re p v 1 e cwr c��� ( ...... .~.o 1..".'.1 �" ~ � f'l l'�ild p 'I .... ~t1on 1 ,I ' of t;,., 1'ax (..'.oa. th~~ te r 1tl J�~S ifiG si 1 n :dt r urn nt 328 �

L..� l~ - ;). l 80 0~ qll Jl' col ec t1 le tro tb p tt tono:rs 1ncom t o f n � to: in~.; on he l 62 et:t �1� 01 � t o re .. -' t �, in lt.ls e or 50 ureh rge +..~ fteienc ~ int re t, lus ~22.5 ~t ad 1- r eld ee t - !ilfL ur�e...,"),r e tor 1� 63, ar al e r et . ee1s1cn o1 r pon6 nt . pp ...l �� at � � l"$ ')I oN ar.e<l t 18 ,967 � .5�i, 1 Cl l.~S,.V � of 5' nt 11 ). , �112 , 1. -. tl l< llf !\ 1d p V d d th� t S&i{i ... 11 \,i'.lO 7 1.n't , (3) y otto ~l(e) Qf t #ltll .d ep � liQ \t um t �tr22.S 327

1 . ee tu a . �l) \.)~ � 328