CTA Case No. 149 (Decision)

... PIEPUBLT C OF TRF PHILIPPINEI ;�:<Jv H.T v X: AP.PEALS MA ~l LA � - ... v r -- -... - -. . . - . - ) .s ! t 10 l � l hi$ y. i r th to 1l �l r - _.; 815

... � - t 1 � � .,.. � ( 8 16

� �- - ..���..�.. � .�.�.�.�.�.�..��. ������ ...�.�.�.�.�.�.. . ..... ������� �������� .. .. �������� ��� � � . � ������ ... ,. y ��� �� �� � ���� �� ����� L �������� � ��������� � ) ic (� 8 17

� 14 ,. � � f l � �� l 11 I ,. 1 .t. ch a � t te nett t J t () ... l r tt t r pc h v T'prie in tm fo f1 tf � �n � 1 activities- ot In t r 1 - t to . )( n r c to 0 c t :r i.. 1 l ients xcl t t 0 - �' 818

1 I I l I ' I 1 � � ap 11. � " ? 819

�1 � c \ ide.r 1 J't 1t ,. th . t ett r 0 m .d � 191 � � r. ~ e ' ul) y 1 .. � 6, ;.)'/ ttat on say lq. .. l l I \t. 4!1:'0 l . � � ..,.. p ... ' (;.} 0 .' �� � f 1 'nly r e �s .. fo_ :t: cor.;:;;.i( t ~ �ay � V- .t G rch � ,J.:,~w5 1 an - � "t e � 9 , ;.~J. c., . 11 r. �C~i PP 0 y rec ) 1 . .0 ~- t ) -� vl1 Jun l' J 1 nt p '-1 on .... y .put� t n of ,,\") . ('" ) ! p icd cr ~ee t :on 11 of t " � 11 2~ . dy f~ on f th -.;oll ctor 0 n- , ...u u"'p~ .ct of t 1 ve � y to J I. t t!l~ od o. thu y day n} r fol h cei of to- �' !:) "" -n ... !' r ,. Xa v~n t l ni i6 l _ __..___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __...

� -- 1 t -- � v. wO � � � :l � t in wO ' .I. $ � .l�. .. f a g t VII tb io 0 t i.S l"id ... 1' l ca $ ul � f� c;; ... b ....1.."..'p. ih .... ,. a .:'\ :tt � ' �.r. � 91, ""' pt , r ,, I � �c t!e- % I ell c c . t b 1n . i I 'Y l:EfCOrd of ea e ,. th t """' y I PP s ujiir � c I i � 1 5� I n I I 0 "1: as a I I .. .. ~ .. !> tc If. 5 .... , I I � r I I I ' � f.:.. y crppe an� of' ;i e et er 0 appe ee afeny1�.�ng h1.s request , 821 'II

"l -. - � 1 5. i l'' 8 2 2 ,,. i'

�1 'j � con in . in- --...r tel i ir~ �p rt, l 1, 1 0 i1 � ttbu th 0 � I. H prov!s 01 $ ti ti ��n 1 rt �� u l i l. - 4 1n a nr. dr fi . 14 t .. of 11 rr. �h f� ~, n c t 1 � � ha j y p tlen:. nten ~ ti r v ... ht an l!n91 t '1 ic-..nscd .lh r"n .ci t "'J � 1 w�tl' t c'. r 0 t in 0 H Il l to ta ay 9 n n 0 nt � ro buttr s i ... in u in-G 'lfi'-t ._,:,n , ct--"'r nt h ...... t 1 n I c .:h z: I t i t iU is i cu a 11 t � l veo rt lJ l !.~cd l ~ ::� ~23 J

-. .n 1, � 1$ ... n- �tal, scl o pr ~ t nd fin - u. - � c aid h app ll nt h r �n .. �v u f h l. tion 178� n1 v .. axch� .. "' 9� � 1 � � -:: � 2./"y' rds� r$ Y� !.n c . 1' . � ! led ect r 1 v nu � t th"t . 0 ry, r'e nal D tc 0)d - .1 ym n .. ec fo � 11 tt 1 0 $r -~ .. "11 n in ' 824

1 ... a , e - 11 � - t � � 1 -- n 1 � lt � ., _, ;. 825

1 � 12 .. y! t t l:' o"!na 37~.~ to 1 � ,\.I 1y. ucl vo 0 n p- h ~1 pp l nt t 1.! nt in an � t nt .. p ion 0<' � 0 ... e tl.t ~ .d 10 of uyin appel . �� 1 nly i D' f c1 n . � el J. of 7 'hil. '. c ~,.. h n � rt - ( t v ho l. h ,e 826

� 827

t� � 1 9 .. l oo;; e p .l � 0 no ..h t c nn � J' , 0 p �- vnt ict .t. rtt. hi c y it ~ co .n 1 n n2 . a � 4. . ""' 1 r � J..t. i) I $0 Ct t,ld4!j. - c; n th.i at c ..:.o al o"" .. c n...�P.:ll.t tt &)' e r.t. partic.Jl rl ' c Q t f1:rErt point find pr ti �.o �"- Q� h . c 0 ..:.r: m tld ,r du 1 i .. 'toO . at on p "� 0 ' u� it h:' l:') thi$ c w s 0 :lppallnftt ull: th t rt., denc t tax 1d 0 rt s frt th a 1� � lhe p �l ot p i 82 8

l ... -I .. ""' ipt, ~rhi 1 {p. 6 ) ., g �y:ntn t . 'nde1.. , ft !' ving u.t t $ t to l t. :..th ' "' t s thu ��pp,e t c Chui a f Y� to � 1Q ao l fVt<J:t f n� �h r. f l"ld <--� ,,.f tt r ~.~ ~Ci-~"{ n h '.; ~c 1 A:t1 4 s -.e.1t i .ol..c.. 1& d i ~o,f i .. C . u....t . , 1� vu I tax s siul ,1) J t\. dt~ 1 i t1 � ' ,pf;' s t �;.... ~.._,y,:;r l P,;f:� n ;\ f c - se �nt 0 1 -t(!l" f .-.;;I . lrea y ""'i n it e f o r: n v_r C:'l�~� y~Jr ' !ir:..t~ �; iltV {" \~ 1 l~i '4 ; a� .. n- t Li i ... i app :ren ;.;.'y th� of i� ��� t li . �n t'f;it~tmito 'I c ' t ,...., ... lUd 10 { r f nd o 829

- d f ... om l. h e t:h t � t' unc nt IJh w� ir i. at u� p ym n c :rlc t� ctor ut sp � n � � 830