CTA Case No. 2750 (Decision)

0~) �(/ tIC OF THE PH1LlPPI:'iE8 .'I ' T \X APPEALS ON CIT / � no ... - ...... 27 ) . . - )( ... ... ... ... ... ... ... v �U ... T. � 27 � - - �I T ' .. fl --. --- ---- - . � � ...,. " X � - ... 123

� ... ... hy h h n �19 � u f � m 4 7 c cn J ui i. f d 1I � � e 124

- { o, 6l � ) � � � 76) 12 6

.. -- � f � y . .. 1 127

...., . eof f In di ul 'l v i.e n � nJul � .. n :r: 0 .. f th 128

7 1 t .metric i. � ~t l as j_ 2.9

~ -~ � ',J!/ � ~7 ~~ 27 . ... y, th e n ,:r � c 1 n 2 ,e () ;I ' ue Or w i t< l n� c1 un*'IY '1i (! li 1'1 td rt~ i h .r'c .n d d h 'V lue o� 2a. j ~ . e .. - x! cl� �n qu~ � J 1 .. ~iel 11 ni ( x.elu ~ ng xei��� m~ at f s) , ' ' (, ( t ..,.n .. ld z. � f~:tt' l i.n th f)~ y ccur ".l (; . u,n ' ..if?tl: )f t d .� n + tine in h-, fx X to ,U r"� � n 1) uh n " cr.,., 1 d .. o:r vi he v~lu ' c. .:rtc u. ~ ~r �t.i v.l c. .t c i ;1. �ci~l . 't ~ l ~ ... nvt�1C 130

� ih fl<l y c u c un v~lu 11 , n�../ r f\ 1 $ c nt. j t n cl n' ~ c. -lu �c I h � (:6 ( - r � u~n li - 131 1

� -. c- � � .1.. l.."l :t. h. ~�-t ....: .l . i �c ir. � C) t ic uly 132

- 11 � .. � �� � c in in ) - n l.C l l (� � c i c � y cn 1 n :c�c:: ch 13 3

-� � 1 of f � n � h i c � c n t'cl .l..

� -1 uc v -� l - c ch c ch l cy y .r n vu c n .� 135

� , � e i l' i l 136

275C 2751, 2.752 & 2753 x visi~ns ~ ~lie 1 � in th bs nee o viden.c� to thr contx ry. theze i no b :s1 the~ f re ~ th /ass xt .~ n cf r s on c-nt that he rect valu m~ ~ric on. The _ntm f .the st~ ut r vid~ the saf ~t g ide ~s to t whic. obedience is du - nd fr m ' . ich devla i n is not .;;,ll<.wable. J dilla v � �;ity f l-':"S y , H ..24� ':!9 � Jon 29 , 196.;.; , 2:~ jJil 1349. ) ' � rul d y ~his .cur i th c s~ f ~ sianer f ~u- ~.oms , H' " ;ase .fo . 2717, '"�ecf'mb :r � 29� 1 77 , nc x~itPr~t-d in �he ec nt e ~ o �1:11 :or. o.r ,ti.on {7hi li ��;ins) v:; � .-(lffimlssioner of _,u 0 is , c�r e J 1~ � 2599, -~bxu ry 2 , 197 , �Ie~i .. N~ti ~1 De er fl\ N � 34 , st:::tt"'S '.:tU i e clt~ .rly '- shoul~ be th m coo- sum~ ti n VRlu ~ . nd f . h m c __ .s1 m tion ~~lue "':h>r is i11..Jicat ~ � irt th~ �...c:nsuL ~ � '2tUn:~!Q.iAl , tr <~ .s.�.:,.-.i1j __ :;) invoices. Th 1 vJ h . d li t~r lly d fine . )$ . . . . . . . . ~~ the h m cc sum~tion v . lu~ s 137

�� in the 11<1 .,ll (;\' hex � c ~ts , "'hA o..~ tc ')l ... ng .. h . . . ; ....... ~ \. c~ n iti n x~~J1 f x hip;;l n t 'h). >h"li ~ ine;), nlun .::en l r) "'e:t c~n't o s.uc.. h ._,. ng ~: �,:�� 1<:-:. t-'f""�"-:"1'.� , ~:r nh cf �r.c : �o 1 -~ 1.� ."........., "\.<' "'""" -"'""".',"'"' ort�".'� <1.� ~~-J�l'""'');1.>������t �0 . - �� h . v lu ;. h�rt i"� I k � :> cf ~-h�' ccunt... y t:rcm ~t.ohe:r. <:-XP rt � .qi].::-t ~~ :-!""'� .;,_.;.;.:.;;..;,..;.;..o;.;:;.;,;.;.;.:;,...,~�l~ t riu :-~ �~:: 138

. � � 17 � j 'l'l%i. e ::r i. u � � "'i hi T er ny, cti n ' th n n, e ti c :;, p n P. < 1 s .s. .u n th r.nv v 1~ � ,Q> ch:\n�i \' �ill s �.r. v !."' pr ling �-�� ic � (-4. �� ,h( lt;d odg n c .nn f �i tbo ovi;;)i.on t e th h . r.\ c. nsU":'lp ion v~lu 0 "Ll'liCe n l l be n. v~ d cl X d in onsol A t e .�,m ei 1, d ly d s nt c d co u ;:; n oic v -r p.r c t.e h ment c on in .2~ 7' ,1 n c on . 35 e i": i � r.v�~t:r ~ t ' l7'�' � f e cl- ld +" f re n n e� .. ct� lC 3 � . ., r . (;tii. c c�n hich iflv ic �� sp ci n�t in i d 0t l.d b t r r un .bl .e 139

-� .. 1 - � y

� � -. � ... .' c ) ,~ 1 / , y � 141

... 1 ld e n� c ,. � � I X 1 jj c in n� n l: c 1n t.l �n �1 � v- � 1 ng � ., � <.. c ;o m n' r � ' 11 47 i' , � .. � 749 � ' rnb 1 � f 'J: nf f f by �4 t ./: ~ 142

"� ... .)1 - 1 r ~ � ul n ;c < - "ilv, l' ult c .r.r s� 9 � . -v nu .~.. t -.h oh.l l�.k ce ti y t the ion J: ~h 'h .l l - XC - t te> ' T fun~ r ::\. in.. x . Ji. vie -""' ... ,., ~or ;.1i .-: si cit.. r cf rn;..c n~l � !l wf4- y h ( rcvlsion~ o e~ch vs � . .-.ff vis ' f �" hou...c b -cti n � . i ng /. - s n ;;ho i � �) nd by ht: judgm"'n � to nd � if) judici~l uit fox he l int rn l 143

-2 - c .' � � 7� 7 "... � � ', � � � J 144