CTA Case No. 1822 (Decision)

�tt;-<- /) / j' REPU!11.f C OF THE PHIL! PPJ 'l"E8 COURT OF T.\.X .\Pl>EALS QUEZON CITY - � 0J1 r .... c. � CA 22 II 0 e n.en � r~~ - - - - - - - ... .. .... - .... X I ,C l I 0 ic c 0 r: t' ic lC :1 c n fr t ar 19 1j r- ... II n 10 �tit1on rs l Q<ll. rio .l jf.>t 1 jo. l � ld t �u � rl l :ita~ l hn s Jld II d 1l f n te:t � lit, t: u. lo, o �inc f u n) . � 19 � 0 urp ti n �� .,n er ( b) '~t . al 1 inc r i �n rh 109

� 2 - 2- 0 f 0c i� ( c r r c ly 1 r --~--~~ ~~;~~----> � d i t1- � � � n� � 110

I -o . 1 22 .... 3 - � .I ij i! ,. 111

c - �l - mh 0 ec � f 1n h . 11;1h n th . wn .t � i n,. t0 t. l Jo t"ol h in J.'Ci n. sme t o � cl n y in i in('>t t c~r o- 1: i n. , rm ��~ .. , X c . on J ,;, on .o... ition h t .� r . I? 1 jo~ �1 th h ic\1 ural ti. s 1 � 1 jo ) rt ti .. n l lv � l .j' � n~y n.v r or- l� n '� n l l n r th ;- 112

ZC I ... CT �l - .... 113

... 2 - i n icu ur � y 'h nq 1 i0 on co... r i �I e is fr ct- n1 - tn t 0 ion � t .r fo.ce, :0 t ' l :1 t 0 (' � tJ. n ( d "t -� n n l, 0� lf '..J in � r n �r n t� f n O:t ~ r .n �o d r t � t .... ( >. 1 .... � "joi �cc un ih iQ s" , non J� 114

r - � �1 2 - 7- 9l 0 lJ. 0 � t en tn t � ... n- � �� � � 1 57� 1 2 .11 . 1 o. ) y ~ f.i.i ion o..-: o- . a 1 he n a c n r: ci,t hi r- .r l - in 1 t; yh of 'n to c. �n n,. c ) it 1 or ~ u- tion l e. ( � � i 0 n tio � � l; .. � � o. � 1 � ,. � - 32 r 2 II .97 � ... t n t 1. # ) 1) t e t.Ar .., 1 xable ion ( ) t~l d h d con- t. fi- (4) f- f C!Oh i l C) io 0 �{ i � 29 �� � .ct. 2 � 0 ,ie> i r ! ;~ 115

- � - .. y e � � lll (2 3 ., ; a ct � "4) . ~or uy 1 111. 1 y th h fore- � 197- ... ( � . >. s t fic1 1 1 1 (1) () t n 11 f 'i it n () tin it t - ite ell n in 0 1 ru t \1 i t sr r ti )1: n. f 0 tn n - n t �� ra 1 t f nr - lc v ai ua "cor . ncl e s joi t ... t c ni n 0 �J ( t v. r 1 �u "'� n c- 0 n�- � n 'P r - r If n� l .n ly - i ) r: cl pu - t r on �I l tl 116 I

� ... jo r () n � � ., 1 i r n n r 1 tl r y �� i 1 i r- �� 1r .. � �� iv r� � ,, 117

-o. 1 - 0- ,. 118

'--I 0 '" l -1 .n r 1 n n4 or pvr � 1 l v nu k n n pr eri it ci �h 'c t. t ri tt u .. u 1 r. or t c u -; 1. oc on ..... 119

'I ON ... c� A � o. 1 22 - - 1 t on n1 ting Law �7 120

1 .. I IOt � :. 121

- � 2 - c .� t ( t � � l� l1 1- i 0 - i � I� 122

- ... � � ( � .) - � 1 � �� - ;. 123

- � -1 c� � T .) w1 1 r: ch r h�~ orf t all w .r r ,. 1 r c -i n� i1 I e .t 9 r n iC r: O J; tor 1, r i � (To 3 II ff ' O. 4 ) I no L & t c �� '1 1 .rt n� r1 c ti ) n ne 1 n r 1 d t ..at w n e i r f l ... suc::c in it �h s - g �h pa 0 11 ( nto io q 1 � yc � � � � - � 18 o. � l96 � l 1 � 7.) -in- nt ,r st 0 E'lti i n a- r jo n � �� in e on �n ld .... i ni it u n .9 # 1 t t rn r1 a c rpo ti .. n: corp r t ffic J: ;) ro. on t m e ; p r ct n �� n i vi.. lt 9U1 y r th gist r.d

�2 7- "n � r 1 � �� � l ct 0 4( ) . c 1 1 l 1 � n- � ic r - - � n 1 1 � � . . .., 1� j � � � � .7 125

� 1 4. r� 1j � �� � � � � � � 7. � � � � � � � � � � .2 ������� � � ���� ���� l � � c 'i 1 1 � 1 c 1 t 1j r- 126

� 22 -l 1 7( ) � l h 1 l l � l� 127

I �1 - ( � 1 � � � � -1 9 , 2� � 11 v. � �� l. 1 ( 1� 1 � � L- 1 �1 � y, Lt �� 7) rv � r �� 1 n --o 1 � ll l v1 - 1 1 eo (L � 1 �� u � -l �� � � �� 1 1 128

- � 2 - 11 in i l c 1r..e n 1 # to 1 0 1 n i 1- 1 �( r � (.) . � � 1� � �� y c n � ( � n r ... 77 � � �� or � i � 37. c 11 . v. � 1n n � � � � 7� �� � � �� � 7� 7 � ) r t 0 � l i �J � l '� i j 1i . 129

- �2 - 2- � r he pre n 1 (\ t e n..~ i~ co i n inc lly s in l t l �.1 f c t n� 1� � h h v h .... tv 1 7 n ht r y j- ri r l 0 th ... in t 1� - i f ... c t i -� . ( ;;) � 1� () -� � � �� . . . � L - 11 0 � J.n. o. 1 10. l .) l h�t 11" t il � a ci n t; on r - c c nc ind ss t. lu th t"' ., 1 cl di l i�.s .ceo 0 �ly i1 lejo 0 !I; r t com l int. n c1 130

-� 1 � 1 ~wo r -2 e \1 n n 0 � i rr y ct 1� ic � � 0 n �� i c- j ) �h r cc u d c l nc � i n l n i � u n � � 1 c hr r� � � 197 � 0 i, .~�~. r ,. � 17 131